From Fourth to Nineteenth in a Year: The Risers, the Fallers and the Free-Fallers
A year ago this week Sunderland were fourth and Manchester United were dreaming of the Champions League. Today one is 19th, the other has sacked its manager, and Brighton are second. A quarter of the season is gone. Compare every club with where it stood after ten games last year and three have shot up, three have fallen off a cliff, and two managers have paid for it.
bossFOOTY.The 60-second read
- Up: Brighton (+7 points), Everton (+4), Leeds and Nottingham Forest (+3 each).
- Down: Sunderland (-10), Manchester United and Crystal Palace (-9 each).
- Level: Liverpool and Newcastle have exactly the points they had a year ago.
- The price: United sacked Michael Carrick and Palace sacked Pierre Sage, both on 12 November.
Then and now
Points after ten matches, this season against last
The chart: two ladders and three snakes
Quick guide: each club gets two bars. One is the points it has now, the other is what it had after ten games last season. If the first bar is longer, pop the kettle on. If the second is longer, hide the kettle, because somebody is about to throw it.
Brighton and Everton are the ladders. Sunderland, United and Palace are the snakes, and they are long ones. Losing nine or ten points on your own form in ten games is not a dip. That is nearly a point a game gone missing, like socks in a wash.
What makes it matter is what happened next. Two of the three fallers changed their manager in the same afternoon. The third, Sunderland, has a board telling TEAMtalk it has full confidence in Regis Le Bris. The chart did not sack anybody. But it was in the room.
Brighton: second, scoring at will, and not sorry
Brighton have 22 points, seven more than at this stage last season, and have climbed from 10th to second. Opta Analyst reports it is their best start to a top-flight season. The goals explain it: 26 scored, five more than anyone else, and only seven conceded. A goal difference of +19 after ten games is the best in the league by nine.
The man behind it is Fabian Hurzeler, who is 33 and already in his third season. They have beaten Arsenal 3-0 and won at Manchester City. AFP reports the fans are now openly dreaming of a title challenge, and Hurzeler has not exactly told them to calm down.
Which raises the question nobody at the Amex wants to say out loud. Asked by AFP when supporters could start dreaming about the title, Hurzeler said, “They should be always excited if they watch our game”, before adding that expectations are outside the club’s control. The supporters have their own way of coping: We Are Brighton, the fan site, greeted second place with a piece titled “6 things which could stop Brighton winning the Premier League title”, which is the most football-fan response to good news ever recorded. Our numbers are less nervous. Seven points better than a year ago is a trend, not a fluke.
The transfer angle is the fun bit. Brighton usually sell their best player every summer and get better anyway. This year they bought: Luka Vuskovic arrived from Tottenham for a club-record £50m, per ESPN. A club that sells brilliantly has started buying brilliantly. The rest of the league should be nervous.
Everton, Leeds and Forest: the quiet climbers
Everton are four points and eight places better off under David Moyes, who has just equalled Harry Catterick’s record of 592 games as Everton manager. Thierno Barry has ten goals. Moyes celebrated the latest win by saying he was not sure it was a good performance, because some things never change and we would not want them to.
Leeds are three points up, built on the third-best defence in the league. Forest are also three up, which sounds odd for a side in 16th until you remember how bad last autumn was. Oliver Glasner had one win in nine before beating Manchester City 3-1. He left Crystal Palace in the summer. Hold that thought.
Shirt artwork is original BossFooty design in club colours, not official kit. Season figures from Fantasy Premier League.
The faces of the swing: two smiling, two carrying the shopping
Four players, four different seasons. Barry and Vuskovic are what a good year looks like: a striker who cannot stop scoring and a new signing who settled in a fortnight. Le Fée and Fernandes are what a bad one looks like: good players doing their bit while the building shakes.
The lesson is how thin the line is. Everton did not reinvent football. They found a striker in form. Sunderland did not forget how to play. Their chances have stopped going in: eight goals from about 15 expected. One hot streak is the difference between sixth and nineteenth.
For January, it tells you who will be shopping. The clubs on the snakes all need the same thing, somebody to put the ball in the net or keep it out, and they will all be ringing the same agents.
Sunderland: from fourth to nineteenth, with a passport stamp
Last November Sunderland were fourth with 18 points. They now have eight and sit 19th, the largest fall in both points and places. Eight goals in ten games is the lowest total in the division. They had taken one point from six league games before beating Chelsea 1-0, and they lost striker Brian Brobbey to a leg injury during the international break.
The cruel twist is that last season went too well. Finishing seventh earned a place in the Europa League, and Thursday nights have a way of taxing Sundays. Regis Le Bris made eight changes for the Chelsea game after losing in Zagreb in midweek. It worked. He will take it.
Is his job safe? TEAMtalk says the board is fully behind him. Sporting Life has him among the managers feeling the heat. Both can be true. The next four league games are Villa away, Spurs at home, Liverpool away and the derby. That is not a run of fixtures. That is an obstacle course.
What bought the board that calm was one result. Reuters, via TimesLIVE, records that Sunderland beat Chelsea 1-0 for their first league win since August, Enzo Le Fee converting a penalty after Levi Colwill was judged to have pulled down Brian Brobbey. A penalty is a fine way to win and a poor way to plan, and it does not change the number that got them here. Eight goals is still eight goals.
Manchester United and Crystal Palace: nine points worse, two managers lighter
United had 17 points at this stage last season and have eight now, their worst start to a Premier League campaign. It cost Michael Carrick his job, 173 days after he signed a two-year contract. Mauricio Pochettino starts on 18 November. Our profile of the new man is here.
On the terraces the blame has not landed where the sackings did. Writing in The Irish News, columnist Paul McConville, who was in the crowd for the 3-0 defeat by Bournemouth, describes supporters who backed Carrick while turning on the structure above him, and who mostly want assurances that the next appointment will not put the club back at square one within a year or so. It is a fair demand and a slightly optimistic one, given the last decade. The nine-point drop is the players’ and the planners’ as much as any manager’s.
Palace have fallen by the same amount, from 16 points to seven, and are bottom. Pierre Sage was hired from Lens in June to replace Glasner. He lasted until 12 November. So Palace lost the manager who won them the FA Cup, watched him pop up at Forest, and are now nine points worse off while he is three points better. Football can be very rude.
Sage went down swinging, at least. After the 3-1 home defeat by Liverpool that sent Palace bottom, the Press Association reported him insisting, “It’s not from the dream to the nightmare”, and telling a questioner he expected to be in work after the break more than they did. It was a good line and a bad forecast. Nine points worse than last year is a nightmare by any sensible definition.
The Evening Standard reports Thomas Frank is the frontrunner for the Palace job, with nothing confirmed. Whoever gets it inherits the leakiest defence in the league and a striker, Jean-Philippe Mateta, in the last year of his contract.
Meanwhile, one year on
A BossFooty cartoon. Generic characters in club colours, not real people. Nobody actually said this.
Transfer talk: the fallers are about to go shopping
Manchester United. A centre-back is the reported priority, with Jarrad Branthwaite, Nathan Collins and Calvin Bassey named by the Daily Mail’s Chris Wheeler via TEAMtalk. One report, no bids. Early Our shortlist piece.
Crystal Palace. A manager first. After that, Mateta’s contract, and a midfield that Chelsea are reported to be eyeing, with Adam Wharton named by CaughtOffside as an alternative target. Early
Sunderland. No solid January names yet, which for a side with eight goals is either admirable calm or a worrying nap. Brighton, meanwhile, have no reported needs at all. That is what 26 goals buys you: a quiet phone.
The table after ten matches
| # | Club | P | W | D | L | GF | GA | GD | Pts | Form |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Arsenal | 10 | 9 | 0 | 1 | 15 | 5 | +10 | 27 | WWWW |
| 2 | Brighton | 10 | 7 | 1 | 2 | 26 | 7 | +19 | 22 | WWLW |
| 3 | Man City | 10 | 7 | 0 | 3 | 21 | 13 | +8 | 21 | LLLW |
| 4 | Liverpool | 10 | 5 | 3 | 2 | 14 | 10 | +4 | 18 | WLWW |
| 5 | Chelsea | 10 | 5 | 1 | 4 | 19 | 16 | +3 | 16 | LWLW |
| 6 | Everton | 10 | 4 | 4 | 2 | 12 | 10 | +2 | 16 | WWLL |
| 7 | Bournemouth | 10 | 4 | 3 | 3 | 16 | 14 | +2 | 15 | WWWW |
| 8 | Brentford | 10 | 3 | 5 | 2 | 16 | 11 | +5 | 14 | LWDL |
| 9 | Leeds United | 10 | 3 | 5 | 2 | 10 | 8 | +2 | 14 | WLDD |
| 10 | Aston Villa | 10 | 3 | 4 | 3 | 14 | 17 | -3 | 13 | DDWW |
| 11 | Tottenham | 10 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 10 | 11 | -1 | 12 | LWWW |
| 12 | Newcastle | 10 | 3 | 3 | 4 | 13 | 16 | -3 | 12 | DLWL |
| 13 | Hull City | 10 | 2 | 5 | 3 | 11 | 11 | 0 | 11 | LDDL |
| 14 | Ipswich Town | 10 | 3 | 2 | 5 | 15 | 20 | -5 | 11 | LDDL |
| 15 | Fulham | 10 | 2 | 4 | 4 | 10 | 12 | -2 | 10 | DDWW |
| 16 | Nottingham Forest | 10 | 2 | 3 | 5 | 9 | 13 | -4 | 9 | WLDL |
| 17 | Coventry City | 10 | 3 | 0 | 7 | 10 | 19 | -9 | 9 | LWLL |
| 18 | Man United | 10 | 1 | 5 | 4 | 14 | 19 | -5 | 8 | DLLD |
| 19 | Sunderland | 10 | 2 | 2 | 6 | 8 | 17 | -9 | 8 | WLDL |
| 20 | Crystal Palace | 10 | 2 | 1 | 7 | 10 | 24 | -14 | 7 | LLLL |
Table as of 13 November 2026, after 10 matches. Form shows the last four league results, newest first.
The table: last year’s top four has a hole in it
Find Sunderland and United in that table and remember where they were twelve months ago. Then find Brighton and Everton. The league has not been shuffled. It has been tipped out and put back by somebody in a hurry.
What the table hides is that two clubs have stood perfectly still. Liverpool and Newcastle have exactly the points they had a year ago, despite both changing manager in the summer. All that drama, all that money, and the needle has not moved.
What it means next: the fallers have further to climb than the risers have to fall. Sunderland and United both create plenty and should improve. Brighton’s finishing may cool. Expect the gap to close a little by Christmas, though not enough to save anybody’s blushes.
The BossFooty view
Our numbers say two of the three big fallers are unlucky. Sunderland and United both create like top-half sides. Palace are different. They concede the most chances in the league by a distance, and that is not bad luck, that is a problem.
The stories back that up. United have a new manager with a record of making teams run. Sunderland have a board holding its nerve and a win to build on. Palace have an empty dugout and four straight defeats.
So our call: Brighton stay in the top four, United and Sunderland climb, and Palace’s season depends entirely on who walks through the door next. The biggest riser of the next ten games will be a team from the current bottom five. The table is that wrong.
The BossFooty call
Brighton are real. United and Sunderland bounce. Palace need the right manager, fast.Confidence: moderate
- Opta Analyst: how the table compares with last season after ten games
- Sports Mole: league table
- AFP via Express Tribune: Brighton dream of a title charge
- ESPN: Vuskovic joins Brighton
- Stats Perform via SoccerNews: Moyes after Coventry
- PA via Irish News: Sunderland 1-0 Chelsea
- TEAMtalk: Sunderland’s stance on Le Bris
- Crystal Palace FC: statement on Pierre Sage
- Evening Standard via Yahoo: Frank the frontrunner
- Reuters via The Star: Forest appoint Glasner
- Sky Sports: Carrick sacked
- TEAMtalk: United’s centre-back targets
- AFP via Express Tribune: Brighton dream of a title charge
- We Are Brighton: Brighton fan site
- Reuters via TimesLIVE: Sunderland beat Chelsea
- PA via The Irish News: Sage after the Liverpool defeat
- The Irish News: a United fan column on the Old Trafford mood
BossFooty predictions are data analysis for discussion. They are not betting advice. BossFooty is independent and is not affiliated with the Premier League or any club.
More from BossFooty
Analysis
Postcards From the Break, Part Three: Wirtz Scores Twice, Robertson Passes Dalglish and Arsenal Hold Their Breath
The last postcards from the November break: Florian Wirtz hits two for Germany, Andy Robertson breaks Scotland's caps record in a 4-0 defeat, Zubimendi limps off and the long-haul flights land just before matchweek 11.
Transfers
Captain Wanted, Striker Banned, Shop Still Shut: Brentford’s Very Brentford November
Manchester United have Nathan Collins on their January list. Igor Thiago is banned for three games, one of them at Old Trafford. Brentford's answer to everything is a polite no.
Transfers
The Captain Fancies Old Trafford and the Coach Was Due the Sack: Fulham’s January Has Two Ends
Calvin Bassey is on Manchester United's list and reportedly open to it. Fulham want £40m-plus, lead the race for a Betis winger, and have a head coach who was tipped to be gone by now.
Comments
Loading comments...
AnalysisbossFOOTY.
TransfersbossFOOTY.
TransfersbossFOOTY.