Fourth Time Lucky: Pochettino Finally Gets Manchester United, Now That It Is on Fire
Manchester United looked at Mauricio Pochettino three times and picked somebody else. On the fourth go they said yes. All it took was the worst start in the club’s Premier League history and a 4-4 draw that looked like a cry for help.
bossFOOTY.The 60-second read
- The appointment: Mauricio Pochettino was confirmed on 13 November, a day after Michael Carrick was sacked. He starts on 18 November on a two-and-a-half-year deal, to the summer of 2029.
- The position: 18th, eight points, one win in ten. It is United’s worst start to a Premier League season.
- The attack is fine: 14 goals, 1.6 xG and 17.7 shots per game.
- The defence is the problem: 19 conceded and no clean sheet in 11 matches in all competitions.
- The CV: a league title and two cups in Paris, a Champions League final with Tottenham, a World Cup last 16 with the USA. No major trophy in England.
- First match: Liverpool away on 22 November. Welcome back, Mauricio.
Shirt artwork is original BossFooty design in club colours, not official kit. Season figures from Fantasy Premier League.
The four faces of the job: a captain, a runner, a kid and a shield
Those four cards are the Pochettino project in miniature. He needs his captain onside, his full-backs flying, his young players believing and somebody, anybody, standing in front of the defence. At the moment he has one and a half of those.
Start with Bruno Fernandes, because everything at United does. He is the top scorer with four and the man who took the corner for the 96th-minute equaliser against Villa. He is also, per Sky Sports, the man who has turned down a second contract offer, and who publicly questioned the previous staff’s game plan after a 4-1 defeat at Como and was dropped for the next match. A new manager’s first job is usually the defence. This one’s first job might be a coffee with the captain.
The other three are the fun part. Sky’s tactical preview tips Patrick Dorgu to thrive in a system built on attacking full-backs, and Pochettino’s whole career is a list of young players he made better. Kobbie Mainoo should be delighted. Carlos Baleba, the summer’s big signing, is the midfielder this team most obviously misses.
What happened: a summit in Monaco and a sacking in Manchester
Carrick left on 12 November, 173 days into a two-year contract he had earned by finishing third as interim. Sky Sports reports that chief executive Omar Berrada and football director Jason Wilcox went to see Sir Jim Ratcliffe in Monaco the day before, and that the decision was signed off while Carrick was still taking training. Gary Neville, never a man to keep it in, called the way it was handled disgusting on Sky Sports News.
ESPN reports that Pochettino was the only candidate United spoke to directly. On the money, the outlets cannot agree: ESPN has a release clause of about $10 million to take him from the United States job, Sky puts it nearer £7m. Either way it is the cheapest thing United have bought in years. He takes charge of the USA’s two matches against Haiti first, then starts at Carrington on Wednesday 18 November.
The part that will sting in the accounts department comes from David Ornstein. Speaking on The Athletic’s podcast, as relayed by TEAMtalk, he said United could have taken Pochettino for free in the summer when his United States contract was running down, and that hiring him now meant a release clause of around 10 million dollars plus more for his staff. The Peoples Person, a United fan site, put the clause at around 7.4 million pounds. Ornstein’s summary of the earlier snubs was, “They clearly didn’t think Pochettino was the man then.” Paying in November for what was free in July is not a tactical problem, but it tells you plenty about the people a manager now has to rely on for a centre-back.
United’s statement described his football as high-intensity, attacking
. On the evidence of this season, the attacking part is already there. The intensity, less so: Sky notes United rank 19th in the league for distance covered. Pochettino teams run. This one strolls.
Michael is, and always will be, a Manchester United legend.
That is the nicest sentence anybody has ever been sacked with. It is also the United way now: legend on Wednesday, P45 on Thursday. Carrick won 15 of his 32 games as permanent manager and was applauded by the crowd after his last match, which is more than the people who sacked him got.
The fans’ anger, as PA reported from the Villa game, was pointed upstairs: at the Glazers, at Ratcliffe, at Wilcox. That matters for Pochettino. He walks in with the crowd on his side and the boardroom under the spotlight. For a new United manager, that is as good as it gets.
That reading is backed by someone who was in the stands. In The Irish News, columnist Paul McConville, who was at the 3-0 defeat by Bournemouth, writes that supporters want an overhaul of the football operation and some assurance that the next appointment does not return the club to square one inside 18 months. He also notes, drily, that it is unclear who exactly upstairs wanted Pochettino. So the new man starts with the crowd on his side and the boardroom on trial, which is the right way round for a builder.
The man: a builder, a believer, and nobody’s magician
Pochettino’s career reads like a man walking slowly up a staircase and occasionally being pushed back down it. Espanyol, where he started and left with the club bottom. Southampton, where he took an unfashionable side to eighth and made half of them England internationals. Then Tottenham, the job that made him.
The long road to Old Trafford
- 2009-12Espanyol. First job. Learns to do a lot with a little
- 2013-14Southampton. Eighth, a club-record points total
- 2014-19Tottenham. Third, second, a Champions League final. No trophy
- 2021-22PSG. Ligue 1, the French Cup, and still the exit door
- 2023-24Chelsea. Sixth, a League Cup final, gone by May
- 2024-26USA. Gold Cup final, World Cup last 16 on home soil
- Nov 2026Manchester United. At last. Sort of
Look at that timeline and one pattern jumps out. He builds brilliantly and finishes second. Spurs came third, then second with 86 points, then reached a Champions League final, and the trophy cabinet stayed locked throughout. His only major honours came at Paris Saint-Germain, where winning the league is roughly as surprising as rain in Manchester.
That is the worry and the hope in one. United do not need a trophy this season. They need a team. And building a team out of young, hungry players who run until they drop is the one thing nobody disputes Pochettino can do. Sky describes his preferred shape as a 4-2-3-1 with a high press and full-backs who attack like wingers.
And the history is delicious. ESPN’s Mark Ogden counts three previous occasions when United considered him and went elsewhere, starting with Jose Mourinho in 2016. He is the ex they kept nearly calling. Now they have, and the house is a bit of a state.
United against the league average
Per game, Premier League 2026-27
The chart: half a football team, and it is the wrong half
Quick guide: two pairs of bars, United against the average Premier League side. Top pair is goals scored, and the bars are almost level. Bottom pair is goals conceded, and United’s bar wanders off on its own like a toddler in a supermarket.
That is the inheritance. Fourteen goals puts United level with Liverpool and Aston Villa. Their expected goals figure, 1.6 a game, is higher than Liverpool’s 1.2, and they take 17.7 shots a game. A team that scores four at home against Villa does not have a chance-creation problem. It has a what-happens-next problem.
At the other end only Crystal Palace (24) and Ipswich (20) have conceded more than United’s 19. They have not won away in the league, with eight conceded in five away games, and the run without a clean sheet is 11 matches in all competitions. For Pochettino this is almost good news. Fixing a defence with a new idea is quicker than inventing an attack from nothing. It just has to start at Anfield.
What he inherits: a treatment room and a contract pile
The squad does not make it easy. Manuel Ugarte is out with a cruciate ligament injury and Carlos Baleba with a hamstring problem, which removes the two midfielders best suited to protecting a back line. Benjamin Šeško is out until January. Luke Shaw and Marcus Rashford are also on the injury list.
And then there is the superstition. A Sun report, relayed by AfricaSoccer, points out that Matthijs de Ligt has started every season at United under a different manager, and supporters online have duly christened it a curse, one offering the new boss, “Pochettino, I’m so sorry in advance”. It is a cracking joke and a terrible piece of analysis: the defender did not concede 19 goals on his own, and no hex explains a side with no away win. Pochettino’s problem is a thin squad, not a haunted one.
Then there is the paperwork. Fernandes, Harry Maguire and Shaw are all out of contract in the summer, with club options, per Sky. Sports Illustrated reports Lisandro Martinez is also in his final year. And the summer spending went on midfielders: Baleba for £65m, Andrey Santos and Youri Tielemans. No centre-back. No left-back. No striker. Somebody built an extension and forgot the roof.
There is Europe too. United have two wins and two defeats in the Champions League, including a 4-1 loss at Como that started the Fernandes row. Pochettino’s first six games are Liverpool away, Sporting away, Brentford, Newcastle away, Coventry and RB Leipzig. Nobody could call it a soft landing.
Dorgu, Mainoo and Baleba fit the running, pressing style. Goal, citing The Sun, also names Lisandro Martinez and Mason Mount as players who could gain.
The same report lists Shaw, Maguire, Tielemans, Andrey Santos and Rashford as players with something to prove. It is one outlet’s read, not a verdict.
Bruno Fernandes. Captain, contract unsigned, dropped once already this season. Keep him happy and half the job is done.
Winners and losers: who should be smiling at Carrington
Those cards sort the squad into the people a Pochettino team is built for and the people it tends to leave behind. The principle is simple. His sides press, sprint and play through young legs. If you are 21 and can run all day, congratulations. If you are 31 and prefer to manage your minutes, there may be a conversation coming.
Treat the names with care. The winners-and-losers list comes from Goal’s write-up of a Sun report, and no manager has picked a team yet. What we can say from the record is that he has form for this: Southampton’s kids, Tottenham’s Dele Alli and Harry Kane years, Cole Palmer’s breakout season at Chelsea. Reputation does not get you picked. Running does.
What it means for Anfield: expect energy before structure. With a few training sessions he cannot rebuild a defence, but he can pick the eleven who will chase. That alone would be a change.
January: a centre-back, please, and some clarity on the wallet
The meter sits in the middle for a reason. Everybody agrees United need a defender. The Daily Mail’s Chris Wheeler, as relayed by TEAMtalk, names Everton’s Jarrad Branthwaite, Brentford’s Nathan Collins and Fulham’s Calvin Bassey as potential targets. Early That is one original report and no bids. We go through all three in our centre-back shortlist.
The money is where the experts fall out. ESPN’s Mark Ogden expects January funds to be extremely limited. Sky’s Rob Dorsett thinks Pochettino will be backed properly. Both cannot be right, and the answer probably depends on what Ratcliffe makes of the league table by Christmas. Early
Up front, TEAMtalk’s reading of the Mail is that a loan striker is more likely than a big purchase while Šeško recovers. Early And the Fernandes contract is the one item graded Strong: Sky reports the second offer was rejected. A manager who wants to build around his captain will want that sorted before the window opens, not after.
Meanwhile, at Old Trafford
A BossFooty cartoon. Generic characters in club colours, not real people. Nobody actually said this.
What to watch at Anfield
Pochettino will have had a handful of training days with a squad returning from international duty, so a full change of system is unlikely. The first sign of his work will be how United defend without the ball: how high the line sits, and whether a side that conceded four at home to Villa is harder to play through.
There is one thing in his favour. Liverpool have won one of five at Anfield this season, and nobody expects United to get anything. A free hit is a rare gift for a United manager. Our full preview makes Liverpool 56% favourites.
The BossFooty view
Our numbers say United are a mid-table attack bolted to a relegation defence, and that sides like that usually drift up the table once the goals against calm down. The story says more than that. A captain with an unsigned contract. A crowd at war with the owners. Two holding midfielders injured. And a manager who has never won a major trophy in England, taking over the club that passed on him three times.
Put the two together and here is our call. Pochettino is a good appointment made a year or three late. He will make United fitter, younger and harder to play against, and that alone should lift them clear of trouble. He will not make them contenders this season, and anybody promising otherwise is selling something.
The test is not Anfield. The test is whether the board gives him a centre-back in January and whether Fernandes signs. Get both and this could be the start of something. Get neither and we will be writing another one of these in eighteen months.
The BossFooty call
Out of the bottom three by Christmas. Top half by May. Trophy talk can wait.Confidence: moderate
- ESPN: United confirm Pochettino
- Al Jazeera: Pochettino announced, with the club statement
- Fox Sports: team statistics
- Sports Mole: league and away tables
- Sky Sports: Carrick sacked, the Monaco meeting
- Sky Sports: Pochettino appointed, contracts and fixtures
- Sky Sports: what a Pochettino team looks like
- Sky Sports: Fernandes contract
- Sky Sports: Gary Neville on Carrick’s treatment
- NBC Sports: the club statement on Carrick
- ESPN, Mark Ogden: the three times United passed
- Wikipedia: Pochettino’s career record
- Goal: possible winners and losers
- Sports Illustrated: contracts and targets
- TEAMtalk: centre-back targets, relaying the Daily Mail
- PA via Irish News: fan protests at the Villa game
- TEAMtalk: Ornstein on United and Pochettino
- The Peoples Person: United fan site on the agreement
- The Irish News: a United fan column on the Old Trafford mood
- AfricaSoccer: fans and the De Ligt joke
BossFooty predictions are data analysis for discussion. They are not betting advice. BossFooty is independent and is not affiliated with the Premier League or any club.
More from BossFooty
WSL Stories
Ten Defeats and an Ocean: Is Charlton’s Record Their Fault, or the System’s?
Charlton are the first WSL side to lose their first ten. The scorelines, the late promotion and the money say it is not only about them.
WSL Previews
The Team That Only Draws at Home Meets the Team That Never Draws: Arsenal v West Ham in the WSL
Arsenal have drawn all five home league games. West Ham have not drawn all season. One streak ends on Sunday. Our call: 2-1.
WSL Previews
Eight Goals, Five Unbeaten and No Way Through: Everton v Brighton in the WSL
Everton have just shut out the league's top scorers. Brighton have just lost 3-0 at home. Our call: 1-0.
Comments
Loading comments...
WSL StoriesbossFOOTY.
WSL PreviewsbossFOOTY.
WSL PreviewsbossFOOTY.