Two Down Twice, Level Twice, Sacked Anyway: Man United 4-4 Aston Villa
Manchester United were a goal down after 59 seconds and two down after four minutes. They came back. They went two down again. They came back again, in the 96th minute. And four days later the manager was sacked. Welcome to Old Trafford, where even the comebacks get you fired.
bossFOOTY.The 60-second read
- The score: Manchester United 4-4 Aston Villa, Sunday 8 November.
- The record: Opta says United are the first side in Premier League history to come from two goals down to level twice in one game.
- The finish: Joshua Zirkzee on 90+2 and Patrick Dorgu on 90+6.
- The fallout: Michael Carrick was sacked on 12 November. Mauricio Pochettino has replaced him.
Fifty-nine seconds, and the afternoon was already on fire
Some fans were still finding their seats when Alysson scored. By the fourth minute Nicolas Jackson had made it two. Opta says it is the earliest United have ever trailed 2-0 in the Premier League, which is a record nobody frames.
Then United did what this United side does. They scored. Bruno Fernandes converted a penalty and Youri Tielemans, against his old club, levelled just before half-time. Two-all, and the place was rocking.
It lasted three minutes of the second half. John McGinn scored a penalty, Leon Goretzka added a fourth, and at 4-2 Villa looked finished with the job.
Shirt artwork is original BossFooty design in club colours, not official kit. Season figures from Fantasy Premier League.
The cast: a full-back with other ideas and a captain who would not stop
Dorgu wrecked Villa’s evening. He crossed for Zirkzee’s goal in the 92nd minute, then headed in a Fernandes corner in the 96th. A defender, deciding a game with eight goals in it.
Fernandes was at the start and the end of the comeback, scoring the penalty that began it and delivering the corner that finished it.
And spare a thought for Unai Emery, who was already heading for the tunnel when the equaliser went in. Sports Mole reports he said he thought the game was over. We told that story in Emery Clocked Off Early.
Emery’s side of the story has been argued over ever since. Read Aston Villa, a site that follows the club closely, ran its follow-up under a headline calling the result not unfair on Emery and Villa, which is a remarkably level-headed thing to print after leading 2-0 and 4-2. Higher up the club the mood was less philosophical: Sports Mole relays Villa executive Damian Vidagany questioning the VAR check on Dorgu’s equaliser on social media, though no formal complaint has been reported by anyone we trust. Noise, then, and not news. Four goals from eight shots should win any match, and the reason it did not was at Villa’s end of the pitch, not in the VAR room.
Old Trafford, goal by goal
- 59 secondsAlysson. 0-1
- 4 minsJackson. 0-2
- 16 minsFernandes penalty. 1-2
- 44 minsTielemans against his old club. 2-2
- 48 minsMcGinn penalty. 2-3
- 53 minsGoretzka. 2-4
- 90+2Zirkzee from a Dorgu cross. 3-4
- 90+6Dorgu heads in a Fernandes corner. 4-4
Reading the timeline: brilliant and broken in the same 96 minutes
Eight goals. Two comebacks. One team that scores like a top-six side and defends like it has double-booked.
United deserved something on the balance of play. They had 25 shots to Villa’s eight and eight corners to one. But Villa scored four from six shots on target, because United’s defence makes every visiting striker look clinical. That is 11 matches without a clean sheet.
The crowd’s verdict was aimed upstairs. PA reported chants against the Glazers, Sir Jim Ratcliffe and football director Jason Wilcox. Carrick was applauded off. The fans were furious with nearly everyone except the man who lost his job.
The fan media took the same line as the stands, and took it further. The Peoples Person, the site behind United Peoples TV, watched a double comeback from two down and published an opinion piece headed “Michael Carrick still needs to go, but INEOS first need to clear the decks”. Eight goals, two rescues, and the verdict was: lovely, now change the manager and half the squad. The same site reports that a Stretford End banner told the owners that supporters want them gone more than they want a new stadium. All of that is opinion, loudly held. The 25 shots and the four conceded are the facts, and they point at the same two ends of the pitch.
That’s not going to happen.
He did not walk. He was pushed
Carrick was right. He did not walk away. The club made the decision for him on Thursday 12 November, with one league win from ten and United 18th.
The decision had been trailed well before it was made. David Ornstein of The Athletic reported on 11 November that United were finalising a deal for Mauricio Pochettino, conditional on the club choosing to remove Carrick, as The Peoples Person’s relay of his report sets out. The BBC’s Simon Stone posted the same day that he had been told the Pochettino situation was all but agreed, and PA’s Simon Peach reported that a framework was in place while Carrick was still turning up for work at Carrington. The club has since confirmed the appointment, so that part is no longer a report. It does mean the 4-4 was played by a manager whose successor was already being measured for the coat.
There is something very United about it. The team produces the most dramatic comeback of the season and the manager still does not survive the week. The comeback was the symptom, not the cure. You do not need to score in the 96th minute if you have not let in four.
And the most United detail of the lot is who they are reported to have wanted first. Sky Sports’ Rob Dorsett reports that Carrick was told face to face on Thursday morning, and that the preferred target had been Unai Emery, the man in the other dugout for this very match, only for Villa to refuse and for there to be no buy-out clause in his contract. That is Dorsett’s account and not a club statement, and Sky’s own news story on the appointment carries club sources flatly denying there were differing preferences at all. Two lines from the same outlet that do not quite agree. Whichever is right, United spent the week of an eight-goal thriller with the more interesting drama happening upstairs.
Pochettino inherits an attack that works and a defence that does not. Our full profile of the new man is in Fourth Time Lucky.
Meanwhile, in the tunnel
A BossFooty cartoon. Generic characters in club colours, not real people. Nobody actually said this.
The BossFooty view
We did not publish calls for matchweek 10, so there is no homework to mark. Our calls begin with matchweek 11.
What it means: United are in the bottom three and Pochettino’s first match is Liverpool at Anfield. Our call is Liverpool 2-1. Villa have now conceded four at a side in the relegation zone and host Sunderland, and we have Villa winning 2-1. We would advise Emery to stay until the whistle this time.
- PA via Irish News: United 4-4 Villa report and fan protests
- Opta Analyst: Man United 4-4 Aston Villa in numbers
- PA via Irish News: Carrick after the Villa draw
- Sports Mole: Emery on leaving early
- Sky Sports: Carrick sacked, Pochettino appointed
- Match statistics: Sportradar data feed
- The Peoples Person: relay of David Ornstein on the Pochettino deal
- PA (Simon Peach) via Irish News: Carrick awaits his fate
- Sky Sports (Rob Dorsett): how the Pochettino pursuit unfolded
- Sports Mole: Villa executive on the VAR check
- The Peoples Person: opinion after the draw (fan opinion)
- The Peoples Person: the Stretford End banner (fan opinion)
- Sky Sports: news story on the Pochettino appointment
- Read Aston Villa: follow-up on the draw (Villa-focused site, opinion)
BossFooty predictions are data analysis for discussion. They are not betting advice. BossFooty is independent and is not affiliated with the Premier League or any club.
More from BossFooty
WSL Reports
Eight Saves and a Shrug: Arsenal 1-1 London City Lionesses and Mary Earps Shuts the Emirates
Two goals in 99 seconds, then Mary Earps saved everything. Arsenal have drawn all five home league games. We called 1-1: correct.
WSL Reports
Ten Out of Ten, and Not in a Good Way: West Ham 2-0 Charlton and a Record Nobody Wanted
Viviane Asseyi scored twice and Charlton became the first WSL side to lose their first ten. We called 2-0, and for once we were spot on.
WSL Reports
Four Years of Waiting, One Header, Three Arguments: Aston Villa 1-0 Birmingham City in the WSL
Mathilde Harviken's header settled the first WSL Second City derby since 2022. We called 1-1: close, but wrong.
Comments
Loading comments...
WSL ReportsbossFOOTY.
WSL ReportsbossFOOTY.
WSL ReportsbossFOOTY.