Your say
Three goals at Palace, then two weeks with no Liverpool to watch. I am sleeping properly and I do not care for it. Uncle Rahim, house tipsterFour goals against Villa and the new manager has not even walked in yet. Imagine us when he does. Every title charge starts som... Big Dave, house tipsterLiverpool at home to us next. I have gone 2-0 United. Do not ask me to show my working. Big Dave, house tipsterNottingham Forest have more January plotlines than a soap opera, and the window is not even open. BossFootyManchester United scored four at home to Aston Villa and are still in the bottom three. The new manager is due this week. No pr... BossFootyLiverpool did their January shopping in September. Somebody at Anfield owns a calendar. BossFootyChelsea lost at Sunderland, then reportedly had a bid for a teenager turned down. A rare fortnight in which nobody said yes to ... BossFootyArsenal are five points clear and still window-shopping for a striker. Some habits survive anything. BossFooty
Have yours

WSL Stories

Ten Defeats and an Ocean: Is Charlton’s Record Their Fault, or the System’s?

WSL STORIESWHUbossFOOTY.
Share thisTelegramXFacebookThreads

Charlton Athletic waited 18 years to get back to the top flight of women’s football. It has taken them ten games to set a record nobody has ever set before: ten played, ten lost, the worst start in Women’s Super League history. The easy headline is that Charlton are not good enough. The harder question, and the one the rest of the league should be asking, is whether anyone coming up the way they did would be.

Mind the gapbossFOOTY.
Mind the gap AI-generated illustration. Invented characters, not real people.

A cartoon of the argument and nothing more: one small boat, one oar, and a very long way to the other side.

The 60-second read

  • The record: Charlton are the first WSL team to lose their opening ten matches, the BBC reports. Leicester lost their first nine in 2021-22.
  • The numbers: Five goals scored, 30 conceded, no points.
  • The context: They came up through a play-off, and the Guardian has reported on a widening gap in money and squads between the top two divisions.
  • What next: Aston Villa at The Valley on Sunday 22 November. Our call is that the run ends there.

How you lose ten in a row without being thrashed ten times

The tenth defeat came at West Ham on Sunday, 2-0, both goals from Viviane Asseyi. We told that story in our match report. The BBC’s account, carried by Yahoo Sports, is where the record is confirmed.

What makes it odd is the shape of the run. Yes, there was a 6-0 at home to Chelsea. But the BBC also lists a 1-0 defeat to Manchester City, the champions, and a 3-2 loss at Crystal Palace settled in stoppage time. ESPN’s results list shows a 1-0 cup win over Ipswich in the middle of it all. This is a team that competes for long stretches and then loses anyway. In some ways that is worse. A hammering you can shrug off. Nearly is the thing that keeps you awake.

Eighteen years up, ten games down

  1. 2007-08Charlton drop out of the top tier
  2. May 2026They beat Leicester on penalties in a play-off to come back
  3. 18 JulyTheir first summer signing is announced, the Guardian reports
  4. SeptemberClub-record signing Linda Lif Boama suffers a serious knee injury
  5. 1 NovemberChelsea win 6-0 away at Charlton
  6. 15 NovemberWest Ham 2-0 Charlton. Ten out of ten

Reading the timeline: the trouble started in the summer, not the autumn

Quick guide: the important lines are the second, third and fourth. Charlton did not come up as champions with months to plan. They finished third in the second tier and won a one-off play-off on penalties in late May. Tom Garry’s piece in the Guardian earlier this month points out that their first signing was not announced until 18 July. Other promoted clubs were quicker and bolder: the same article notes Birmingham signed two players from Manchester United and Crystal Palace brought in Bethany England.

Then the one big investment they did make was lost. The Guardian reports that Boama, the club-record signing, suffered a serious knee injury in September. A squad built late, on a smaller budget, lost its headline player before the leaves had turned.

None of this is an excuse. Karen Hills told the Guardian the gap to the rest is getting bigger and that her side is finding out how big every week. That is a manager describing the weather, not complaining about it.

The money: two divisions, two different sports

Here is the part that should worry people beyond south-east London. The Guardian set out the minimum salaries for senior players last season: £42,500 in the WSL against £26,900 in the second tier. A club that goes up has to rebuild its wage bill in a summer, and Charlton’s summer started in late May.

The same piece reports that Charlton’s women’s team made a loss of £1.32 million in the year to June 2025, and that league body WSL Football paid out about £400,000 per club across its two divisions in 2024-25. Put those two numbers side by side. That is a club losing more than three times what the league hands out, and then being asked to compete with Chelsea.

Birmingham’s head coach Amy Merricks, whose side came up as champions and are 13th, described the distance between the divisions to the Guardian as an ocean. When the team that won the second tier says that, it is not one club’s problem. It is the pyramid’s.

On the pitch and in the market: what happens now

The table is blunt. Fourteenth goes down. Thirteenth goes into a play-off. Charlton are six points behind Birmingham in 13th with 16 games left, so this is not over, but they need wins and they do not yet have a point.

The football has one obvious gap. Five goals in ten games. The Guardian’s numbers from the first eight matches were stark too: just six passing moves of ten passes or more. A side that cannot keep the ball cannot rest with it, and a side that cannot score cannot turn a good 80 minutes into anything.

On transfers, an honest line: we found no credible report linking Charlton with any signing, and no report that Hills’s job is under review. January is the only lever left. Whether the budget can pull it is a question nobody at the club has answered in public.

The BossFooty view

Charlton are not the worst team to play in this league. They are the first team to meet this version of it: 14 clubs, bigger budgets at the top, and a play-off route that hands you promotion with the summer already half gone. The record is theirs. The conditions were built by everyone.

Our verdict: the run ends soon, because the performances say it should, and we have called a draw against Aston Villa on Sunday. But one point will not fix what the numbers above describe. If the league wants promoted clubs to be more than a fixture for others to enjoy, the gap is the story, not Charlton. This is analysis for fun, not betting advice.

Share thisTelegramXFacebookThreads

BossFooty predictions are data analysis for discussion. They are not betting advice. BossFooty is independent and is not affiliated with the Premier League or any club.

Keep reading

More from BossFooty

Comments

Loading comments...

Ground photos by Wikimedia Commons contributors, used under Creative Commons licences. Photo credits