Every Bad Run Ends Somewhere: Charlton Athletic v Aston Villa and the Hunt for Point Number One
Charlton Athletic are in the history books, and they would like to leave. Ten league games, ten defeats, a start no WSL side has ever made before. On Sunday, Aston Villa come to The Valley fresh from a derby win, but without the defender who got herself sent off at the end of it. If the first point is ever going to arrive, there are worse days for it than this one.
bossFOOTY.Our cartoonist’s idea of the afternoon: ten broken rungs behind Charlton and one good one within reach. A picture of the hope, not of anything that has happened.
The 60-second read
- The match: Charlton Athletic v Aston Villa, Sunday 22 November, 2pm UK time, The Valley.
- The table: Villa are seventh on 13 points. Charlton are bottom with none.
- Last week: Charlton lost 2-0 at West Ham. Villa beat Birmingham 1-0 in the derby.
- Our call: Charlton Athletic 1-1 Aston Villa. Yes, really.
The record is set. Now for the bit where it ends
The facts first, because they are stark. The BBC’s report on the West Ham game, carried by Yahoo Sports, confirms Charlton are the first team in WSL history to lose their opening ten matches, beating Leicester’s nine from 2021-22. Five scored, 30 conceded. We told the story of the tenth in our match report.
But the same BBC piece makes the case for the defence. A one-goal loss to Manchester City in September. A stoppage-time defeat at Crystal Palace a fortnight ago. And ESPN’s results list shows a 1-0 cup win over Ipswich in between. This is not a side being walked through every week. It is a side that keeps finding new ways to come second.
Villa are the form team here, up to seventh after Mathilde Harviken’s header settled the Second City derby. But the win had a price, and we will come to it.
Shirt artwork is original BossFooty design in club colours, not official kit. Season figures from Fantasy Premier League.
The duel: a goalkeeper auditioning against a defence missing a piece
Koivunen’s card is the one to watch. The BBC reports that Karen Hills picked her at West Ham ahead of regular starter Sophie Whitehouse, and she made saves that kept the score at two. Whether she keeps the shirt we do not know. A manager who has changed her goalkeeper once is clearly not done looking for answers.
Harviken’s card comes with an empty space next to it. Her defensive partner Oceane Deslandes was sent off in stoppage time of the derby. The BBC’s report says two bookings in 47 seconds. Villa’s own report calls it a straight red. Either way a sending-off normally means a suspension, though we have not seen the length confirmed, so treat it as the usual rule and not a fact.
What it means for our call: Villa’s back line has conceded 16 and may now be reshuffled. Charlton have scored five all season. This is the meeting of a stoppable force and a movable object.
The fortnight that sets it up
- 8 NovemberCharlton lose 3-2 at Palace, beaten in stoppage time
- 11 NovemberCharlton beat Ipswich 1-0 in the cup
- 15 NovemberCharlton lose 2-0 at West Ham. Ten from ten
- 15 NovemberVilla win the derby 1-0 and have a defender sent off
- 22 NovemberCharlton v Villa at The Valley
Reading the timeline: the second line is the clue
Quick guide: ignore the league lines for a moment and look at the cup one. Charlton won a football match eleven days before this one. At home. With a clean sheet. The players know what it feels like.
Villa’s line is double-edged. A derby win lifts everyone, and Villa’s website calls this their final league game before the break, so there is no reason to hold anything back. But derbies are draining, and the one they won was an argument from first whistle to last.
Then there is the Tom Garry piece in the Guardian from earlier this month, which reported that Charlton have been without their club-record signing Linda Lif Boama since September. This is a promoted squad missing its biggest investment. The surprise is not that they are struggling. It is that so many of the defeats have been close.
In the dugout: an interim with momentum, a manager with a mountain
Brian Sorensen has been Villa’s interim head coach since Natalia Arroyo was sacked in late September with the club 13th. They are seventh now. He was in charge of Everton until February, according to his successor’s Wikipedia page, so he knows this league well. Nobody has said whether he gets the job for good. The table is making his argument for him.
Hills told the Guardian that the gap between the divisions keeps growing, and she is living it. We have seen no report that her position is in doubt, and we will not invent one. This club came up through a penalty shoot-out. It is owed a point at the very least.
The mood in each camp
Villa: bouncing. Derby wins do that. Charlton: stubborn. The supporters’ trust was talking about momentum before the West Ham game, as we noted in our preview of that match, and people who can find momentum on nought points are not people who give up. Expect The Valley to treat a goal like a cup final.
Transfer talk
An honest line: we found no credible report linking anyone in this match with a move. Charlton’s need is not complicated. Five goals in ten games says striker, and so does everything else. Whether there is money for one in January is a question for the club, and nobody there has said.
The BossFooty view
Our call is Charlton Athletic 1-1 Aston Villa. Let us be straight about it: the numbers say Villa. A side on 13 points against a side on none is not a coin toss.
The story is why we have moved. Villa have drawn four of their ten, concede to most people, and are likely to be missing a defender after an exhausting derby. Charlton are at home, have just changed their goalkeeper, and have been one goal away more often than the table admits. Every bad run ends somewhere. We think it ends here, with a point that will feel like a trophy. This is analysis for fun, not betting advice.
- Sky Sports: Women’s Super League table
- WSL Football: fixtures
- BBC Sport, via Yahoo Sports: Charlton lose their tenth
- ESPN: Charlton recent results
- BBC Sport, via Yahoo Sports: Aston Villa beat Birmingham
- Aston Villa: derby match report and next fixture
- The Guardian, via AOL: Charlton’s start and injuries
- Wikipedia: Scott Phelan (Everton succession)
- Wikipedia: 2026-27 Women’s Super League managerial changes
BossFooty predictions are data analysis for discussion. They are not betting advice. BossFooty is independent and is not affiliated with the Premier League or any club.
More from BossFooty
WSL Stories
Ten Defeats and an Ocean: Is Charlton’s Record Their Fault, or the System’s?
Charlton are the first WSL side to lose their first ten. The scorelines, the late promotion and the money say it is not only about them.
WSL Previews
The Team That Only Draws at Home Meets the Team That Never Draws: Arsenal v West Ham in the WSL
Arsenal have drawn all five home league games. West Ham have not drawn all season. One streak ends on Sunday. Our call: 2-1.
WSL Previews
Eight Goals, Five Unbeaten and No Way Through: Everton v Brighton in the WSL
Everton have just shut out the league's top scorers. Brighton have just lost 3-0 at home. Our call: 1-0.
Comments
Loading comments...
WSL StoriesbossFOOTY.
WSL PreviewsbossFOOTY.
WSL PreviewsbossFOOTY.