Your say
Liverpool at home to us next. I have gone 2-0 United. Do not ask me to show my working. Big Dave, house tipsterEveryone wants a striker in January. Nobody ever says buy a centre-back. This is why I win arguments. Sofia Marin, house tipsterNottingham Forest have more January plotlines than a soap opera, and the window is not even open. BossFootyArsenal 1 Hull 0. The perfect score, right on schedule. United and Villa shared eight goals and got a point each. I rest my case. Sofia Marin, house tipsterThree goals at Palace, then two weeks with no Liverpool to watch. I am sleeping properly and I do not care for it. Uncle Rahim, house tipsterAn international break is two weeks of pretending you are not checking the injury news every hour. BossFootyArsenal are five points clear and still window-shopping for a striker. Some habits survive anything. BossFootyManchester United 4 Aston Villa 4. Eight goals, one point each. The spreadsheet files that under inefficient afternoons. Kwame Mensah, house tipster
Have yours

Stories

Bottom of the League and Out of Patience: The Unravelling of Crystal Palace

STORIESCRYbossFOOTY.
Share thisTelegramXFacebookThreads

Half a year ago Crystal Palace were celebrating silverware. Today they are bottom of the Premier League, their striker is banned, a star forward has scrubbed the club from his social media, and the manager is reported to be days from the sack.

Somebody pulled a threadbossFOOTY.
Somebody pulled a thread AI-generated illustration. Invented characters, not real people.

Update, 15 November: Crystal Palace sacked Pierre Sage on Thursday 12 November and Thomas Frank is reported to be set to replace him, though nothing was confirmed at the time of this update. Read the full story here.

The 60-second read

  • Where they are: 20th, seven points, 24 goals conceded, four league defeats in a row.
  • The manager: Opta Analyst reports Palace are expected to dismiss Pierre Sage during the international break. Not confirmed at the time of writing.
  • The striker: Jean-Philippe Mateta is serving a three-match ban after a red card 13 minutes into the Tottenham game.
  • Next up: Coventry away, 17th against 20th.

How did it come to this?

Start with the summer. Oliver Glasner, the man who won them a trophy, left for Nottingham Forest. Maxence Lacroix and Daniel Munoz were sold. In came Pierre Sage, fresh from winning the French Cup with Lens and being named Ligue 1’s coach of the year. On paper, a clever appointment. On grass, a mismatch.

Sky Sports’ analysis, carried by All Football, put a finger on it: the pressing 3-4-2-1 that worked at Lens depends on winning the ball high and playing fast, and this squad has done neither. Squawka’s numbers had them bottom of the league for take-ons attempted. They are easy to play against and hard to watch.

The fans have been splitting the blame three ways. On The Eagles Beak, a Palace fan site, the verdict was that the system belongs to Sage, the set-piece errors belong to the players, and the failure to replace departed defenders in time belongs to the board. That is a generous amount of blame to go round, and the fan sites have clearly been keeping a ledger. It also matches the numbers: a pressing side that cannot win the ball high and a defence that was sold and not rebuilt is how you end up conceding more than anyone else in the division.

Palace's 2026

  1. MayA cup to celebrate
  2. JuneGlasner goes. Sage arrives from Lens
  3. SummerLacroix and Munoz leave. Mateta in a contract stand-off
  4. OctoberMateta sent off after 13 minutes at Spurs. Three-match ban
  5. NovemberBottom of the league for the first time since 2017

The Mateta problem

Jean-Philippe Mateta has been Palace’s best forward for years, which makes his season a small tragedy in three acts. Act one: a hamstring injury that kept him out from the opening day. Act two: he comes back, starts against Tottenham, and is sent off after 13 minutes for a studs-up challenge on Micky van de Ven that VAR upgraded from yellow. Palace appealed. Palace lost. Act three, still running: a contract stand-off, with LiveScore reporting in the summer that the club might sell if no new deal is agreed, and Football FanCast relaying interest from Nottingham Forest and Manchester United.

So the one player who might score them out of trouble is either injured, suspended or being measured for another club’s shirt.

And the noise around it

The Hard Tackle has reported senior players unhappy with Sage’s training methods, and discontent involving Mateta and Ismaila Sarr. The South London Press noted Sarr deleting photos of the club from his social media. None of that is a crime. All of it is the kind of thing that happens at clubs where the mood has gone.

Sage, to his credit, has not hidden. After the Spurs defeat he said he wanted to be first on the training pitch on Monday, and after going bottom he said his own job was not the most important thing.

It was not enough. Palace confirmed on Thursday 12 November that Sage had left, and Sky Sports set out the record: 16 games in all competitions, two wins from ten in the league and 24 goals conceded, the worst in the division. Three of his staff went with him. His last match was the 3-1 home defeat to Liverpool, and the club has said only that news on a successor will follow. For a man who wanted to be first on the training pitch, it is a rotten way to be first out of the door, but two wins in ten was only ever going to end one way.

I will never give up.

Pierre SageCrystal Palace head coach, after the Tottenham defeatSource

Four words, said after the Tottenham defeat, and you believed him. That is what makes it a sad one. Sage did not sulk, did not blame the board in public and did not stop turning up. He just kept losing, which in this league is the one thing a manager is not allowed to do politely.

It matters for what comes next because the players heard that line too. A dressing room that watched a decent man fight and still get sacked tends to go one of two ways under the next boss: relieved, or guilty. Either can win you a game or two. Neither fixes a defence that has let in 24.

Meanwhile, at Selhurst Park

Crystal PalaceMay: we have won a cup!
Crystal PalaceNovember: we have won two league games.
Nottingham ForestThanks for the manager, by the way. Is the striker available too?

A BossFooty cartoon. Generic characters in club colours, not real people. Nobody actually said this.

The BossFooty view

The South London Press made the fairest point in all this: Sage’s struggles are a symptom of Palace’s problems, not the cause. They sold defenders, lost their manager and have barely had their striker. Any coach would be struggling.

But football does not sack squads. If the reports are right, there will be a new voice in the dressing room before Coventry, and that changes Saturday completely. Our preview makes Coventry favourites. A new-manager bounce is the one thing that could wreck that call, and it would be very Palace to find one.

That new voice looks likely to be a familiar one. The Athletic’s Matt Woosnam, as relayed by SoccerNews, had Thomas Frank in the driving seat before the sacking, and TEAMtalk’s round-up has BBC Sport describing talks as advanced and Fabrizio Romano placing Frank at the head of the list. Reports, all of it: Palace have announced nobody. Whoever it is inherits seven points from ten games and a trip to Coventry on Saturday 21 November, a side reported to be only two points better off. The gap is small. The squad problem we described above is not.

Share thisTelegramXFacebookThreads

BossFooty predictions are data analysis for discussion. They are not betting advice. BossFooty is independent and is not affiliated with the Premier League or any club.

Keep reading

More from BossFooty

Comments

Loading comments...

Ground photos by Wikimedia Commons contributors, used under Creative Commons licences. Photo credits