Sacked on Thursday, Stuck on Friday: Palace Have a Manager-Shaped Hole and a Paperwork Problem
Pierre Sage lasted five months, ten league games and one very long autumn. Crystal Palace sacked him on Thursday, lined up Thomas Frank as the replacement, and then discovered that hiring a manager is like hiring a band: the singer says yes and then you find out the drummer has a lawyer.
bossFOOTY.The 60-second read
- Done: Palace sacked Pierre Sage on Thursday 12 November, ESPN and the Evening Standard report. Three of his coaches went with him.
- The numbers that did it: bottom of the league, seven points, two wins in ten, four straight league defeats and 24 goals conceded, the worst in the division.
- Next man: the Standard says Thomas Frank is set to take over. He has been out of work since Tottenham sacked him in February.
- The snag: RoundTable reports Frank has agreed terms but his backroom staff’s contracts are holding things up. One outlet’s claim, so treat it as that.
- The deadline: Coventry away on Saturday 21 November. Seventeenth against twentieth.
Two sackings in an hour, and Palace were the quieter one
Thursday was a busy day for anyone who types “the club would like to thank”. Manchester United sacked Michael Carrick. About an hour later, ESPN reports, Palace sacked Sage. The first two Premier League dismissals of the season arrived like buses.
We told you this was coming. Our piece on Palace’s unravelling said he was reported to be days from the sack. He had about two.
Sage came from Lens in June on a three-year contract to replace Oliver Glasner, who had left for Nottingham Forest. On paper it was clever. On grass it was 24 goals against in ten games. The Evening Standard reports that players had grown disillusioned with his methods, and that the club had already thought about sacking him in September. That is the Standard’s account; we have not seen Sage’s side of it, and he is entitled to one.
Sage at Selhurst: the short version
- JuneArrives from Lens on a three-year deal to replace Glasner
- SeptemberThe Standard says the club first considers a change
- 7 NovemberFourth league defeat in a row leaves Palace bottom
- 12 NovemberSacked, with three of his coaches
- NowFrank is lined up. Nothing is signed off
Five months from fanfare to farewell
Read that timeline again and look at the gap between June and September. Three months. If the Standard is right, Palace were having doubts before the clocks went back. That is not a sacking. That is a slow puncture.
And it matters for the next man. A squad that stopped listening to one coach in twelve weeks is not a squad that is short of opinions. Whoever walks in is not inheriting a blank page. He is inheriting a dressing room that has just won an argument.
For our numbers, it explains a lot. Palace actually create chances. What they could not do under Sage was stop the other lot creating better ones. A new voice can fix organisation faster than it can fix talent, and organisation was the problem.
Frank says yes. Frank’s friends are still reading the small print
So, Thomas Frank. The Standard reported on Thursday that he is set to become Palace manager. He has been free since Tottenham let him go in February, and he knows what a relegation scrap looks like from his Brentford days, mostly because he spent years avoiding them.
Then came the weekend, and no announcement. RoundTable reports that Frank himself has agreed terms and that the delay is over contracts for the staff he wants to bring: Justin Cochrane, Chris Haslam and Joe Newton are the names it gives. Read Crystal Palace says Football Insider has reported a similar pause. Strong that Frank is the choice. Early on why it is taking so long.
The club’s own statement said only that an update on the appointment would follow in due course. “Due course” is doing a lot of work. We could not find a report naming who takes training in the meantime, which tells you how tidy the handover has been.
Four out of five, and the fifth is a signature
Four out of five. Not five, because nobody at Palace has said the words. An established outlet says he is the man; a second says the deal is agreed in principle. What is missing is the bit where it becomes real.
Could it fall apart? Deals stuck on staff contracts usually get done, because by that stage both sides have told too many people. But “usually” is not “always”, and every day it drifts is a day closer to Coventry with nobody in charge who expects to be there in a fortnight.
There is a wrinkle above all this too. Football Insider has reported the owners exploring a sale of the club. Appointing a manager while the “for sale” board is being painted is not ideal. It is, however, very Palace.
Meanwhile, at Selhurst Park
A BossFooty cartoon. Generic characters in club colours, not real people. Nobody actually said this.
Why Coventry and Hull are grinning
That cartoon is the fixture list being cruel. Palace’s next two games are Coventry away and Hull at home. Those are the two matches a bottom club circles in red. They are also the two matches Palace may play with a manager who has had three training sessions, or none.
Coventry are 17th, two points ahead. Win there and Palace climb out of the bottom three’s basement. Lose and the gap is five with a new man starting from behind.
The transfer angle follows straight on. A new manager in November means a new shopping list in January, and Frank’s teams have always been built on set pieces, strong centre-backs and a striker who runs all day. Expect the links to start the moment the ink dries. We will have that piece when he has the job.
The BossFooty view
Our numbers never thought Palace were the worst team in the league. Our eyes disagreed, and our eyes were right, because numbers do not measure a squad that has stopped believing its coach.
Sacking Sage was the easy bit. The appointment is the test. Frank is a sensible, grown-up choice who organises teams for a living, and organisation is exactly what is missing. If he is in the dugout at Coventry, expect a bounce in effort, if not in quality.
Our call for Coventry v Palace was 2-1 to Coventry and it stays there. A new-manager bounce is real, but it needs a new manager. Until Palace produce one, we trust the table.
The BossFooty call
Frank is appointed this week, but too late to save the Coventry trip.Confidence: fairly high on Frank, medium on the result
BossFooty predictions are data analysis for discussion. They are not betting advice. BossFooty is independent and is not affiliated with the Premier League or any club.
More from BossFooty
WSL Reports
Eight Saves and a Shrug: Arsenal 1-1 London City Lionesses and Mary Earps Shuts the Emirates
Two goals in 99 seconds, then Mary Earps saved everything. Arsenal have drawn all five home league games. We called 1-1: correct.
WSL Reports
Ten Out of Ten, and Not in a Good Way: West Ham 2-0 Charlton and a Record Nobody Wanted
Viviane Asseyi scored twice and Charlton became the first WSL side to lose their first ten. We called 2-0, and for once we were spot on.
WSL Reports
Four Years of Waiting, One Header, Three Arguments: Aston Villa 1-0 Birmingham City in the WSL
Mathilde Harviken's header settled the first WSL Second City derby since 2022. We called 1-1: close, but wrong.
Comments
Loading comments...
WSL ReportsbossFOOTY.
WSL ReportsbossFOOTY.
WSL ReportsbossFOOTY.