Eight Changes, One Penalty, Nine Yellow Cards: Sunderland 1-0 Chelsea
Sunderland lost their captain after four minutes. They had made eight changes. They had 31 per cent of the ball. And they beat Chelsea 1-0 for their first league win since August, because football occasionally remembers that it is supposed to be fun.
bossFOOTY.The 60-second read
- The score: Sunderland 1-0 Chelsea, Sunday 8 November.
- The goal: Enzo Le Fée from the penalty spot on 36 minutes, after Levi Colwill brought down Brian Brobbey.
- The blow: captain Granit Xhaka went off injured after four minutes.
- The table: Sunderland are off the bottom. Chelsea have lost four of ten and dropped out of the top four.
Everything went wrong for Sunderland, and then they won
Régis Le Bris made eight changes from the Europa League defeat to Dinamo Zagreb, which is the selection of a man with nothing left to lose. Then Granit Xhaka limped off inside four minutes and Jules Ahoka had to come on cold.
Chelsea should have taken control. They had the ball, as they always do. What they did not have was an idea. Cole Palmer went down early and VAR decided the contact was outside the box.
Then, on 36 minutes, Levi Colwill brought down Brian Brobbey. Referee Jarred Gillett pointed to the spot. Enzo Le Fée rolled it into the bottom corner past Mike Penders, and the Stadium of Light remembered what a lead felt like.
As for whether it should have been given at all, the decision has had expert backing since. Former referee Dermot Gallagher supported the award on Sky Sports News’ Ref Watch, as relayed by Sports Mole, and nobody we trust has reported an appeal or any ban arising from the afternoon. Chelsea can argue about the whistle if they like. A side with that much of the ball should not be in a position where one whistle settles it.
Shirt artwork is original BossFooty design in club colours, not official kit. Season figures from Fantasy Premier League.
The cast: the man who took it and the man who won it
Le Fée gets the goal, and a penalty under that sort of pressure is never as easy as it looks. Sunderland had not won in the league since beating Fulham in August. Somebody had to hold their nerve.
That drought is why the goal was worth more than three points to the man in the dugout. Sky Sports had reported before the match, as relayed by VAVEL, that RĂ©gis Le Bris still had the backing of the board, and the fan verdict since, going by LiveScore’s summary of Roker Report, is that the win has eased the pressure on him. Sunderland’s fan writers have otherwise been thin on the ground this week, which we choose to read as celebration. First league win since August: you would not be at a keyboard either.
Brobbey did the dirty work. He drew the foul for the penalty and had other chances, including a volley that went wide. With Xhaka gone, Sunderland needed someone to occupy Chelsea’s centre-backs on his own. He did.
How long Brobbey has to carry that load depends on the Xhaka news, and so far there is not much of it. Le Bris said afterwards that it looks like a calf injury and that there is no timeframe yet, according to Sports Mole’s injury update, which adds that Switzerland have withdrawn him from their squad. The club has not published a scan result, so everything beyond that is guesswork. What we can say is that Sunderland won this one without him for most of it, and they will need to learn how to do that again.
A mention too for Chemsdine Talbi, making his first league start of the season, and for the subplot of Jordan Henderson starting for Chelsea against his old club and losing.
The Stadium of Light, against the odds
- 4 minsXhaka off injured. Ahoka on
- Early onPalmer goes down. VAR: outside the box
- 36 minsColwill fouls Brobbey. Le Fee scores the penalty. 1-0
- Second halfChelsea have the ball. Sunderland have the lead
- Full timeFirst league win since August
Reading the timeline: 69 per cent of the ball, two shots on target
This is a timeline with very little Chelsea in it, which is remarkable for a team that had 69 per cent of possession.
Here is the number that should worry Xabi Alonso. Chelsea had six shots all game and two on target. Sunderland, with 31 per cent of the ball, had exactly the same. All that passing bought Chelsea nothing.
Chelsea’s own supporters have read those numbers the same way, only more wearily. The Boys of the Kings Road newsletter filed its match piece under frustration, the chief one being that none of it came as a surprise, while The Pride of London went for a list, “The 3 biggest losers from Chelsea’s poor performance against Sunderland”, and argued that the false nine experiment is working for neither Cole Palmer nor anyone else. That is fan opinion and should be taken as such, but it is hard to tease a take that the shot count agrees with. Sixty-nine per cent of the ball, two efforts on target, and a fanbase united in confusion.
It was not pretty either. Nine yellow cards, five of them for Sunderland, who committed 17 fouls. Le Bris will not care. Alonso, to his credit, refused to blame the officials. That leaves only his own team to blame, which is a less comfortable conversation.
None of which, on the reporting available, puts Alonso in any danger. football.london’s Chelsea correspondent Bobby Vincent writes in a reader Q&A carried by AOL that it is very unlikely Chelsea would sack him even if they miss out on the Champions League, and that the owners have handed him more power than any of his predecessors. That is a correspondent’s read and not a club statement. In the same piece he reports that defender Maxence Lacroix could miss the rest of 2026 with a hamstring injury and that a midfielder is the January priority, with Bournemouth’s Alex Scott the most likely target, a report with a long way to run. Six shots in ninety minutes suggests the shopping list might want a second page.
Meanwhile, at the final whistle
A BossFooty cartoon. Generic characters in club colours, not real people. Nobody actually said this.
The BossFooty view
We did not publish calls for matchweek 10, so there is no homework to mark. Our calls begin with matchweek 11.
What it means: Sunderland are still in the relegation zone but no longer bottom, and they travel to Aston Villa, who have just thrown away a 4-2 lead. We have Villa winning 2-1. Chelsea are out of the top four and host Leeds, a side nobody enjoys playing. Our call there is 1-1.
- PA via Irish News: Le Fee penalty sinks Chelsea
- Football Web Pages: results and scorers
- Match statistics: Sportradar data feed
- football.london (Bobby Vincent) via AOL: Alonso, Lacroix and January
- Sports Mole: Xhaka injury update
- VAVEL: relay of Sky Sports on Le Bris and the board
- Sports Mole: Ref Watch on the penalty
- Boys of the Kings Road: Sunderland 1 Chelsea 0 (fan opinion)
- The Pride of London: three biggest losers (fan opinion)
- LiveScore: Sunderland round-up, including Roker Report (fan opinion)
BossFooty predictions are data analysis for discussion. They are not betting advice. BossFooty is independent and is not affiliated with the Premier League or any club.
More from BossFooty
WSL Reports
Eight Saves and a Shrug: Arsenal 1-1 London City Lionesses and Mary Earps Shuts the Emirates
Two goals in 99 seconds, then Mary Earps saved everything. Arsenal have drawn all five home league games. We called 1-1: correct.
WSL Reports
Ten Out of Ten, and Not in a Good Way: West Ham 2-0 Charlton and a Record Nobody Wanted
Viviane Asseyi scored twice and Charlton became the first WSL side to lose their first ten. We called 2-0, and for once we were spot on.
WSL Reports
Four Years of Waiting, One Header, Three Arguments: Aston Villa 1-0 Birmingham City in the WSL
Mathilde Harviken's header settled the first WSL Second City derby since 2022. We called 1-1: close, but wrong.
Comments
Loading comments...
WSL ReportsbossFOOTY.
WSL ReportsbossFOOTY.
WSL ReportsbossFOOTY.