Two Out, One Staying, Two In: Forest’s January Needs a Flow Chart
Some clubs have a quiet November. Nottingham Forest have a forward cleared to leave, a goalkeeper who has asked to go, a striker Brazil wants back, and a shopping list that runs from south London to Santos. They have also just beaten Manchester City 3-1 with their first home goals of the season. Pass the popcorn.
bossFOOTY.The 60-second read
- Out, probably: TEAMtalk report Forest have approved a 30 million euro January exit for French forward Arnaud Kalimuendo.
- Wants out: goalkeeper John Victor has told the board he wants to leave, according to ESPN’s Bruno Andrade.
- Staying, he says: Igor Jesus, valued at 40 million euros, with Flamengo and Botafogo asking.
- In, maybe: Crystal Palace’s Jean-Philippe Mateta and Santos teenager Gabriel Bontempo.
- The manager: Oliver Glasner, appointed in July, had one league win in nine before beating City.
Shirt artwork is original BossFooty design in club colours, not official kit. Season figures from Fantasy Premier League.
Three strikers and a club that cannot decide how many it wants
Look at those three cards. All forwards. One Forest own and will not sell. One Forest own and has just remembered how to score. One belongs to somebody else and Forest are reported to want him anyway. And that is before we get to the forward they are trying to sell.
It is a very Forest situation. This is a club that had scored six league goals from chances worth more than fourteen before the City game, the worst finishing in the division. The response to a finishing problem has been to collect strikers like fridge magnets.
What it means for January is that somebody has to make sense of it. That somebody is Oliver Glasner, working for an owner not famous for his patience. No pressure.
The exits
Start with the one that looks most advanced. TEAMtalk’s exclusive says Forest have signed off on a January sale of Kalimuendo at 30 million euros. A club does not approve an exit unless it has decided the player is not part of the plan. Early
The human story is a short one. TEAMtalk say he has played barely more than a hundred minutes and has not scored, and that he is open to leaving, with Eintracht Frankfurt keen. A striker who cannot get on the pitch at a club that could barely score for two months has read the room.
The detail worth dwelling on is the shape of the deal. TEAMtalk’s Fraser Fletcher reports that Forest would prefer a permanent sale at up to 30 million euros but would accept a loan with an option or obligation to buy, and that Eintracht Frankfurt are watching, with a loan the likeliest route for them. In other words Forest have named their price and then, in the next breath, explained how you might avoid paying it. That is why we rate the exit as believable: a club that flexible about the paperwork has already decided on the outcome.
John Victor is a different kind of story, because it comes from the player’s side. Bruno Andrade of ESPN reports the goalkeeper has made it clear to the board that he wants a move when the window opens, and that a price has been set. Goalkeepers who are not playing rarely enjoy it. Goalkeepers who say so out loud are usually halfway to the airport. Early
The one who will not be pushed
Igor Jesus is the twist. He has not had regular football, and clubs in Brazil have noticed: Flamengo and his old side Botafogo are both said to have asked. ESPN Brazil put Forest’s valuation at 40 million euros, which is a polite way of saying no.
That price tag is a “do not disturb” sign. Nobody in Brazil is paying forty million euros for a striker with one league goal, and Forest know it. It fits what the Telegraph, as cited by Football Whispers, says about owner Evangelos Marinakis: reluctant to sell key players, happy to move fringe ones.
Sport Witness add the detail that matters. The striker does not want to go home yet and has not asked to leave. Juventus and Porto made strong enquiries in the summer, so he has options in Europe if Forest ever change their mind. For now he is staying to fight for his place, which, given the next section, will take some fighting.
The manager’s angle: Glasner, the owner and one very useful Saturday
Oliver Glasner won the FA Cup and a European trophy with Crystal Palace, then swapped south London for the City Ground in July. Reuters reported Marinakis calling him a winner at his unveiling. Four months later he had one league win in nine and Sporting Life was noting that this is an owner who went through four managers in nine months.
He has not been shy about what he found. After a 2-0 defeat at Brentford, VAVEL reported a combative press conference in which he promised an end to compromises and told his squad, “We are not a spa and wellness hotel.” It is a wonderful line and a revealing one. Managers do not talk like that when they think the problem is talent, and our numbers agree with him: a side that makes this many chances and allows this few is short of edge, not ability.
Then came Manchester City. Three goals, the first at home all season, two of them from Liam Delap. PA reported Glasner joking afterwards that he had outrun Enzo Maresca on the touchline, and saying Delap now had to keep working to reach his best shape. That is a manager enjoying himself for the first time since August.
It changes January. A manager on the brink gets told who is leaving. A manager who has just beaten City gets asked who he wants. Football Whispers reports Forest are eyeing up to three signings, and there is money: the sale of Elliot Anderson to City brought in a reported £116m.
Reports relayed by Football FanCast say Forest are prepared to compete with Manchester United.
And yet they want another striker
Liam Delap scored twice in the win over Manchester City. You might think that settles the centre-forward question. Reports relayed by Football FanCast say Forest are nonetheless prepared to compete with Manchester United for Palace’s Mateta, who has reached double figures in the league three seasons running.
The tug-of-war has a delicious subplot. Mateta was Glasner’s striker at Palace. Palace are now bottom, have sacked Glasner’s successor and have Mateta in the final year of his contract. The old boss turning up to take the best player would be the rudest thing to happen to Palace since, well, the last four results.
Add Bontempo, the Santos teenager Forest’s South American scouts are said to be pushing hard for, and you have a club trying to sell two attackers, keep a third and buy two more. Oliver Glasner’s whiteboard must look like a London tube map. Early
Forest's four plots
- Plot oneKalimuendo: exit approved at 30 million euros, per TEAMtalk
- Plot twoJohn Victor: tells the board he wants out, per ESPN
- Plot threeIgor Jesus: Brazil asks, Forest say 40 million euros, he says no thanks
- Plot fourMateta and Bontempo: the incomings, both at the rumour stage
- BonusDelap scores twice against City and complicates everything
The plots, side by side: believable exits, hopeful arrivals
Lay the four stories next to each other and a pattern appears. The departures come with detail: a price, a player’s own wishes, a named interested club. The arrivals are vaguer: “prepared to compete”, “pushing hard”.
That is normal. Selling is something a club controls. Buying depends on somebody else saying yes, and Palace have no reason to say yes to anybody until they have a manager. There are other names floating about too. Sports Mole relays reports of interest in Birmingham’s Phil Neumann and a possible offer for Fenerbahce’s Archie Brown. Early on both.
The wild card is Delap. Every goal he scores makes an expensive new striker harder to justify and Kalimuendo’s exit easier to wave through. He may be the most important figure in Forest’s January without being in a single rumour.
The rumour meter: the door is open, somebody has to walk through it
Three out of five. The club is reported willing. The player is reported willing. That is two of the three things a transfer needs. The third is a buyer with thirty million euros, or a loan with an option, and that part is not done.
John Victor leaving would rate about the same. A reserve goalkeeper who wants to play, at a modest price, with clubs back home interested: these deals tend to happen quietly in the second week of the window.
Igor Jesus leaving would be a one. Mateta arriving, a two at best. If you want a single sentence: Forest’s squad gets smaller before it gets bigger.
What the fans make of it
Written by BossFooty, not by supporters. A fortnight ago the mood was grim: no home goals all season and a manager under the lamp. Then the City Ground watched its team put three past Manchester City, and the owner was reported leaping out of his seat. Forest fans have earned a few weeks of enjoying themselves. They will also know that at this club, calm is something that happens to other people.
There was always a patient camp, mind. Back in September LeftLion, the Nottingham culture magazine, ran a Left Brian column arguing that after a season of managerial churn Forest finally had a coach with a clear plan, and that the real chaos came from above the dugout and from window-season headlines. It read as optimistic at the time and positively prophetic the Saturday City left empty-handed. We would only add the usual caution: one very good afternoon does not turn a column into a prophecy, and January at this club has a habit of rewriting the plot.
Meanwhile, at the City Ground
A BossFooty cartoon. Generic characters in club colours, not real people. Nobody actually said this.
The BossFooty view
Our numbers say Forest are far better than 16th: fifth in the league for chances created, third for chances allowed. What they lacked was a finisher, and Delap may have just volunteered.
The exits are more believable than the arrivals. Expect Kalimuendo and John Victor to go, Igor Jesus to stay, and the Mateta talk to cool unless Palace’s season gets worse. Delap’s two goals just made the expensive option harder to justify.
The story to watch is Glasner and his owner. Beat Bournemouth and he goes into January with authority and a budget. Lose a couple and the same window becomes somebody else’s to plan. At Forest, it only ever takes two games.
The BossFooty call
Kalimuendo and John Victor out. Igor Jesus stays. No Mateta.Confidence: moderate
- TEAMtalk
- Football FanCast
- Sport Witness
- TEAMtalk: Kalimuendo exit approved
- Flashscore Brazil, relaying ESPN: John Victor and Igor Jesus
- SoccerNews: Igor Jesus, Flamengo and Botafogo
- Football Whispers: three January signings
- Reuters via The Star: Forest appoint Glasner
- PA via Irish News: Glasner after beating City
- Sports Mole: Neumann
- Sports Mole: Archie Brown
- Sporting Life: managers under pressure
- VAVEL: Glasner press conference after Brentford
- LeftLion: Left Brian column on Glasner, a Forest supporter view
BossFooty predictions are data analysis for discussion. They are not betting advice. BossFooty is independent and is not affiliated with the Premier League or any club.
More from BossFooty
WSL Stories
Ten Defeats and an Ocean: Is Charlton’s Record Their Fault, or the System’s?
Charlton are the first WSL side to lose their first ten. The scorelines, the late promotion and the money say it is not only about them.
WSL Previews
The Team That Only Draws at Home Meets the Team That Never Draws: Arsenal v West Ham in the WSL
Arsenal have drawn all five home league games. West Ham have not drawn all season. One streak ends on Sunday. Our call: 2-1.
WSL Previews
Eight Goals, Five Unbeaten and No Way Through: Everton v Brighton in the WSL
Everton have just shut out the league's top scorers. Brighton have just lost 3-0 at home. Our call: 1-0.
Comments
Loading comments...
WSL StoriesbossFOOTY.
WSL PreviewsbossFOOTY.
WSL PreviewsbossFOOTY.