Second City, First Derby in Years: Aston Villa v Birmingham City in the WSL
Birmingham City were relegated from the Women’s Super League in 2022. On Sunday they walk back into a top-flight Second City derby, against an Aston Villa side that sacked its manager in September and still has an interim in charge. Neither club is where it wants to be. That is what makes a derby dangerous.
bossFOOTY.The 60-second read
- The match: Aston Villa v Birmingham City, Sunday 15 November, 2pm UK time.
- The table: Villa are 9th on 10 points. Birmingham are 13th on 6.
- The dugouts: Brian Sørensen has been Villa’s interim manager since 28 September.
- Our call: 1-1.
Villa: the sacking stopped the bleeding, not much else
Aston Villa spent the summer buying experience, including Mathilde Harviken and Amalie Vangsgaard from Juventus, as the Independent reported. Four league games later they were second bottom and Natalia Arroyo was out, the day after a 4-0 defeat at Tottenham.
Brian Sørensen, the former Everton manager who had been working as Villa’s technical advisor, took over on an interim basis. He is still there. Villa have climbed to ninth, and they took a point at Arsenal a fortnight ago, so the patient is stable.
Even he has not pretended the job is settled. Read Aston Villa, a site that covers the club closely, reported in early October that Sorensen admitted uncertainty over his role while taking his share of the blame for the start. Since then Goal’s preview lists back-to-back defeats, 1-0 to Manchester United in the league and 4-1 to Liverpool in the cup. An interim with an open-ended brief and two losses behind him is not who you would choose to send into a derby, which is partly why we cannot make Villa more than narrow favourites.
Stable is not the same as fixed. Villa have two wins from nine. Four of their games have been draws. They lost last weekend. And they still have not named a permanent manager.
Shirt artwork is original BossFooty design in club colours, not official kit. Season figures from Fantasy Premier League.
The one Villa player England trust
Kendall was the only Villa player in Sarina Wiegman’s September England squad. In a side that lost its leading scorer to Tottenham in the summer, she is the nearest thing Villa have to a star.
Derbies are usually decided in midfield, by whoever keeps their head while everyone else is losing theirs. If Kendall runs this game, Villa win it. If it turns into a scrap, Birmingham will fancy their chances.
Birmingham City: the long road back
- 2022Relegated from the WSL
- May 2026Promoted as champions of the second tier
- Round 8Lose 4-1 at home to Tottenham
- Now13th: one win, three draws, five defeats, 21 goals conceded
Reading the timeline: back in the big time, and finding it big
Four years away, promoted as champions, and then reality. Birmingham have won once in nine. They have conceded 21, which only Charlton can beat.
Last weekend was the latest instalment. VAVEL’s report on the 4-1 defeat at London City Lionesses called it “another rough defeat for the Blues”, with Oceane Hurtre, their top scorer, getting the consolation. That is the pattern in miniature: Birmingham can find a goal, they just cannot stop the other lot finding several, and 21 conceded in nine is the number Amy Merricks has to shrink before anything else improves.
But look closer and they are not being blown away every week. Three draws, including a 2-2 with Brighton, and a 2-1 defeat at Everton. They can score: 11 goals is more than Villa have managed.
Thirteenth place means a relegation play-off at the end of the season. Birmingham are four points behind Villa. Win this and they are one point behind their neighbours and the whole table looks different.
The BossFooty view
Our call is 1-1. The numbers make Villa narrow favourites at home but see very little between two sides who draw a lot and win rarely.
There is recent precedent for it too. Goal’s preview points out that these two already met in the League Cup in October and finished 1-1, so the fixture has form for cancelling itself out. We would have landed on the same scoreline without that, but it is nice when history turns up to agree with you.
The story pushes it towards the draw as well. Villa are a team without a permanent manager and Birmingham are a team with nothing to lose. Derbies between nervous sides tend to end level. This is analysis for fun, not betting advice.
- Wikipedia: 2026-27 Women’s Super League table, teams and managerial changes
- The Independent via Yahoo: Aston Villa sack Natalia Arroyo
- Express and Star: Villa Women sack boss
- FBTOD: WSL results by round
- England Football: Wiegman’s September squad
- Goal: Aston Villa v Birmingham City preview
- VAVEL: London City Lionesses 4-1 Birmingham City report
- Read Aston Villa: Sorensen on the interim role
BossFooty predictions are data analysis for discussion. They are not betting advice. BossFooty is independent and is not affiliated with the Premier League or any club.
More from BossFooty
WSL Previews
The Gatecrashers Want More, the Visitors Want a Second Goalscorer: London City Lionesses v Crystal Palace
London City are third and annoyed they only drew at Arsenal. Palace are 12th and short of goals. Our call: 2-0.
WSL Previews
Three at Brighton, and the Reward Is the League Leaders: Liverpool v Chelsea in the WSL
Liverpool have just won 3-0 away. Chelsea have conceded five all season and have a European night in their legs. Our call: 0-2.
WSL Reports
Eight Saves and a Shrug: Arsenal 1-1 London City Lionesses and Mary Earps Shuts the Emirates
Two goals in 99 seconds, then Mary Earps saved everything. Arsenal have drawn all five home league games. We called 1-1: correct.
Comments
Loading comments...
WSL ReportsbossFOOTY.