Sold the Engine, Kept the Car: Chelsea’s £125m Hole in Midfield
On deadline day Chelsea sold Enzo Fernandez to Manchester City for a reported 125 million pounds. Then the window shut. Then somebody at Stamford Bridge presumably looked at the midfield and said: ah. Ten games later Xabi Alonso has tried five different pairings in there, lost four league matches, and been told the player he wants is staying at Bournemouth.
bossFOOTY.The 60-second read
- Chelsea did not replace Fernandez and want a midfielder in January.
- Fabrizio Romano says the ideal signing is Bournemouth’s Alex Scott.
- Bournemouth are reported to have said no for January.
- The back-up chatter: Arsenal’s Martin Zubimendi, and a Liverpool target who TEAMtalk say is leaning Chelsea’s way.
- The manager: Xabi Alonso, in his first season, has used five midfield pairings in nine league games, per FourFourTwo.
Shirt artwork is original BossFooty design in club colours, not official kit. Season figures from Fantasy Premier League.
The wish list: one who is not for sale and one who plays for the leaders
That is Chelsea’s midfield search in two cards, and neither is good news. The first choice belongs to a club that has just pulled the shutters down. The second plays for the team at the top of the league, who would sooner sell the stadium than strengthen a rival in January.
It tells you how the autumn has gone. A club that spent the summer buying forwards, including Morgan Rogers for a reported £117m, is now shopping for the one thing it sold. It is like trading your front door for a chandelier and then wondering about the draught.
And it matters for the table. Chelsea are fifth, but they concede more chances than they create. A midfield you have to re-pick every week is usually why.
How to lose a midfielder and not notice until September
Selling Fernandez was defensible. The money was enormous and City wanted him badly. Selling him on the last day with no replacement lined up is the part that came back to bite. As one deadline-day review put it, the move returned to haunt Chelsea, who did not manage to land a successor.
That price tag is the whole argument for the sale and the whole argument against it. A hundred and twenty-five million pounds buys a lot. It does not buy time, and time is what Chelsea ran out of. Sports Illustrated reports they had a £47m deal for Monaco’s Lamine Camara accepted on deadline day, only for Monaco to pull out. So there was a plan. It did not survive the day.
Xabi Alonso has spent the autumn working around the gap. Chelsea sit fifth, which is fine, and eleven points off the top, which is not what the squad cost.
The manager’s angle: Alonso and the five pairings
Xabi Alonso arrived in the summer on a four-year deal, after spells in charge of Bayer Leverkusen and Real Madrid, to replace Liam Rosenior. He was one of the great midfielders of his generation. Which makes it almost cruel that the one thing his new team lacks is a midfield.
FourFourTwo counted five different central pairings in his first nine league games and accused him of overthinking. Fair or not, the results look like a man still experimenting: beaten at home by Spurs, a good win over Manchester United, then a 1-0 defeat at Sunderland in which Chelsea had most of the ball and did little with it. Sports Mole reported Alonso furious with the display.
To his credit he has not hidden behind referees. After a disputed penalty at Sunderland he said the mistake was Chelsea’s own, per Stats Perform. And he has talked up Romeo Lavia. But praising what you have is what managers do while the club looks for what you need.
How Chelsea got here
- Deadline dayEnzo Fernandez joins Manchester City. A Camara deal collapses
- SeptemberWindow shuts with no replacement
- OctoberAlonso tries pairing after pairing
- 8 NovLose 1-0 at Sunderland, a fourth league defeat
- This weekRomano names Alex Scott as the ideal signing
- NowBournemouth reported to rule out January
The Scott problem
Romano’s reporting is clear: Scott is the one. An England international at a club that usually sells. The usual script fell apart this week when Bournemouth were reported to have ruled out a January exit for him. Strong
The numbers behind that “no” are eye-watering. Flashscore’s Dean Jones reports that Bournemouth value Scott internally at more than 110 million euros, that an earlier Chelsea offer of 70 million euros was rebuffed, and that sources insist he will see out the season on the south coast. Jones adds that Chelsea may try to line the deal up for the summer instead. Put that next to the £125m Chelsea banked for Fernandez and you see the joke: the replacement is priced at almost exactly what the original fetched.
The timeline shows why Chelsea are stuck. Every step since deadline day has made them need a midfielder more and made Scott harder to get. They had a £64m bid rejected in the summer, according to Flashscore’s Dean Jones. Bournemouth have since won eight in a row and value him above £80m.
Chelsea’s comfort is the contract. Scott is into the last 18 months of his deal and has not agreed a new one. Chelsea can make life uncomfortable now or simply come back in the summer, when the price will be kinder. Whether Alonso’s midfield can wait that long is another matter.
So who else?
Zubimendi is the headline-writer’s favourite. He has been linked with leaving Arsenal, and one report this week read a hint about Chelsea into his comments. Treat that with a pinch of salt the size of the Shed End: Arsenal are top of the league and have no reason to strengthen a rival. Early
More interesting is a line buried in TEAMtalk’s Liverpool coverage: one of Liverpool’s midfield targets is now expected to choose Chelsea instead. No name was attached with confidence, so we will not attach one either.
CaughtOffside names Crystal Palace’s Adam Wharton as the alternative to Scott. Early Palace are bottom and have just sacked their manager, so that is at least a seller who might pick up the phone. And Sports Mole relays a Football Insider claim about Frenkie de Jong, which we mention only so you know we have seen it. Early
Jones’s list of fallbacks backs that up. The same Flashscore report names Roma’s Manu Kone and Monaco’s Lamine Camara alongside Wharton as the January alternatives, and says Alonso’s priority is protection in front of the defence. That chimes with our own numbers: a side that concedes more chances than it creates does not need another artist, it needs a bouncer.
The rumour meter: desperate buyer, relaxed seller
Two out of five for Scott specifically. The wanting is a five. The getting is a one. Average it out and you land here.
Ask a different question, whether Chelsea sign any midfielder in January, and the needle jumps to four. They cannot go another half-season picking names out of a hat. The only doubt is who, and how much over the going rate they pay.
That is the trap. Every selling club in Europe knows Chelsea have £125m in the bank and a hole in the team. Nobody gives a discount to a man who walks into the shop shouting that he is desperate.
What the fans make of it
Written by BossFooty, not by supporters, and we could not find solid reporting of the mood in the stands. What is on the record is the football: four defeats in ten, a side scoring more than its chances deserve, and a famous midfielder in the dugout without a settled midfield on the pitch. You do not need a poll to guess how that goes down. Selling a star to a title rival is forgivable if it works. Chelsea are eleven points behind the leaders.
What we can point to is the argument on the fan sites, and it is a proper one. Over at The Pride of London, a Chelsea fan site, one writer made the hopeful case back in September that Scott is the fix for a thin midfield, while another has since written the case against: a fee north of £90m would drain the budget, and the defence needs the money more. He does generously allow that “Scott may become a very good Premier League midfielder”, which is the sort of praise you give a house you have already decided not to buy. Bournemouth supporters, for their part, need only read the valuation above to know their club is not the one sweating here. Our view has not changed: the need is real, the price is silly, and both of those can be true at once.
Meanwhile, at Stamford Bridge
A BossFooty cartoon. Generic characters in club colours, not real people. Nobody actually said this.
The BossFooty view
Our numbers already had Chelsea as the league’s biggest over-performers: 19 goals from chances worth about 13, and more chances conceded than created. The story explains the numbers. A team without a settled midfield cannot control games, so it wins the ones where the finishing is hot and loses the ones where it is not.
Chelsea will sign a midfielder in January because they have to. It probably will not be Scott and it certainly will not be cheap. The lesson costs 125 million pounds and reads: buy the replacement before you sell the player.
Until then, expect more of the same. A win, a defeat, a new pairing, a cross manager. Alonso is too good a coach for this to last. But even he cannot pass the ball from the touchline.
The BossFooty call
A midfielder arrives in January. Not Scott. Wharton is the name to watch.Confidence: moderate on a signing, low on the name
- FootballTransfers
- 3 Added Minutes
- TEAMtalk
- Sports Illustrated: replacing Enzo Fernandez, and the Camara deal that collapsed
- Al Jazeera: Chelsea appoint Xabi Alonso
- FourFourTwo: Alonso’s midfield pairings
- Sports Mole: Alonso after Sunderland
- Stats Perform via SoccerNews: Alonso on the officials
- beIN Sports: Alonso on Lavia
- Flashscore, Dean Jones: Chelsea’s rejected bid for Scott
- CaughtOffside: Scott and Wharton
- Sports Mole: the de Jong claim
- Flashscore (Dean Jones): Bournemouth stance and valuation on Alex Scott
- The Pride of London: Chelsea fan site, the case against a January move for Scott
- The Pride of London: Chelsea fan site, the case for Scott
BossFooty predictions are data analysis for discussion. They are not betting advice. BossFooty is independent and is not affiliated with the Premier League or any club.
More from BossFooty
WSL Stories
Ten Defeats and an Ocean: Is Charlton’s Record Their Fault, or the System’s?
Charlton are the first WSL side to lose their first ten. The scorelines, the late promotion and the money say it is not only about them.
WSL Previews
The Team That Only Draws at Home Meets the Team That Never Draws: Arsenal v West Ham in the WSL
Arsenal have drawn all five home league games. West Ham have not drawn all season. One streak ends on Sunday. Our call: 2-1.
WSL Previews
Eight Goals, Five Unbeaten and No Way Through: Everton v Brighton in the WSL
Everton have just shut out the league's top scorers. Brighton have just lost 3-0 at home. Our call: 1-0.
Comments
Loading comments...
WSL StoriesbossFOOTY.
WSL PreviewsbossFOOTY.
WSL PreviewsbossFOOTY.