Your say
Chelsea lost at Sunderland, then reportedly had a bid for a teenager turned down. A rare fortnight in which nobody said yes to ... BossFootyManchester United have appointed Mauricio Pochettino. He inherits a side in the bottom three that scores four at home and does ... BossFootyManchester City return from the break at home to Fulham, a fortnight after losing 3-1 at Forest. Two weeks is a long time to th... BossFootyChelsea sold a midfielder for a reported 125 million pounds and forgot to buy another. We have all left the house without our k... BossFootyNottingham Forest 3 Manchester City 1. The international break arrived at exactly the right time for one of those clubs. BossFootyLiverpool did their January shopping in September. In my day we called that being organised. Now it is a strategy. Uncle Rahim, house tipsterCoventry, Ipswich and Hull are all in the bottom eight after ten games. The Premier League welcome pack remains a league table ... BossFootyThree in the morning, teh tarik in hand, Liverpool on the screen. Doctor says it is bad for me. Doctor supports Everton. Uncle Rahim, house tipster
Have yours

Transfers

Captain Wanted, Striker Banned, Shop Still Shut: Brentford’s Very Brentford November

BREMUNBREMUNvBRENTFORD AT HOMEbossFOOTY.
Share thisTelegramXFacebookThreads

Brentford spent the summer doing something deeply out of character: buying nearly £100m of players and selling almost nobody. November has restored normal service. Their captain is on Manchester United’s shopping list, their centre-forward has been banned for shoving a man in the face, and the club’s answer to both is a calm, familiar no.

The shop that used to sell everything now sells nothing. Odd time to start.bossFOOTY.
The shop that used to sell everything now sells nothing. Odd time to start. AI-generated illustration. Invented characters, not real people.

A cartoon of the month, not a record of it: the captain behind the counter, the customer at the door, and the number nine on the naughty bench.

The 60-second read

  • Nathan Collins: on United’s January centre-back list, per the Daily Mail, talkSPORT and Football Insider. A £40m fee has been “suggested”. No bid. Strong on the interest.
  • Igor Thiago: banned for three matches after his red card at Brighton. The appeal failed. Confirmed
  • He misses: Everton, Manchester United and Arsenal. Yes, that Manchester United.
  • Also wanted: Yehor Yarmolyuk, by Trabzonspor, according to TEAMtalk. Early
  • A striker signing? We could not find a single report that Brentford want one.
COLLINSDEFCOLLINSDEF
Nathan CollinsBREBrentford0 goals · 0 assists · 241 mins · form 0.3Captain. United's idea of a grown-up.
THIAGOFWDTHIAGOFWD
Igor ThiagoBREBrentford2 goals · 3 assists · 824 mins · form 4.0Three-match ban. Back for City on 5 December.
WILSONFWDWILSONFWD
Callum WilsonBREBrentford0 goals · 0 assists · 57 mins · form 1.034, six sub appearances, suddenly essential.
YARMOLYUKMIDYARMOLYUKMID
Yehor YarmolyukBREBrentfordTrabzonspor want a chat. Brentford do not.

Shirt artwork is original BossFooty design in club colours, not official kit. Season figures from Fantasy Premier League.

United want the captain. Of course they do

The story started with the Daily Mail’s Chris Wheeler, who reported that Collins and Fulham’s Calvin Bassey had joined Everton’s Jarrad Branthwaite on United’s January list. Football Insider’s Pete O’Rourke then said United had set their sights on Collins as the long-term answer to Harry Maguire, with talkSPORT’s Alex Crook naming him too, all gathered up by TEAMtalk.

You can see the logic. Collins is 25, an Ireland international, captain since last year and built like a centre-back drawn by a child: tall, square, heads things. United have let in 19 in ten. They are not looking for flair.

O’Rourke’s own verdict, in that TEAMtalk piece, was that Collins would “tick a lot of boxes” and that Brentford will not want to lose him. Both halves of that are true, and the second half is the one that matters in January.

Man Unitedfront of the queue
Everyone wantsNathan Collins
BrentfordNot mid-season

Shortlist interest, per the Daily Mail's Chris Wheeler and Football Insider. No approach or bid has been reported.

The rope: United pull, Brentford do not move

One suitor, one holder, and the holder has done this before. Liverpool and Tottenham were linked with Collins in the summer, CaughtOffside notes, and he is still in west London.

What has changed is Brentford’s mood. Sports Mole’s tally of the summer has them spending £96.6m and bringing in about £5m, with Mamadou Sangaré arriving from Lens for a club-record fee. This is a club that used to sell a star every summer and bank the cheque. This year it kept everyone and went shopping. Selling the captain five months later would be an odd sequel.

The £40m in the reports is a suggestion, not a quote from Brentford, and TEAMtalk expect them to want more. We could not find his contract length in any report we trust, so we are not going to guess it. But nothing about a club sitting eighth says “needs the money”.

Thiago's fortnight

  1. 8 NovemberSent off after 23 minutes at Brighton when a yellow card is upgraded on review
  2. 10 NovemberBrentford appeal the red card
  3. 11 NovemberAppeal rejected. Three-match ban stands
  4. 23 November to 2 DecemberMisses Everton at home, Manchester United away and Arsenal at home
  5. 5 DecemberAvailable again, against Manchester City

The ban: three games, and look who is in the middle

Read it top to bottom. The red card came at Brighton, where referee Michael Oliver went to the screen and told the stadium Thiago had pushed an opponent in the face, as Sports Mole reported. Brentford appealed. The club’s own site confirmed it failed.

So the man who scored 22 last season misses Everton, United and Arsenal. The fixture computer has a sense of humour: Collins could spend 28 November at Old Trafford marking the forwards of the club that wants to buy him, with his own striker watching from the stand. Keith Andrews said afterwards that his players had been provoked and needed to be cuter, according to the Argus. Translation: stop taking the bait.

Cover is thin. Callum Wilson is 34 and has not started a league game. Kevin Schade and Dango Ouattara can play through the middle if asked nicely. Kaye Furo, 19, is working back from a foot injury. The Beesotted podcast’s latest episode is titled “Life Without Thiago”. Not a hymn of optimism, then.

PUB TALKHERE WE GO
Rumour meterSmokeNathan Collins leaving Brentford in JanuaryCredible shortlist interest from United. No bid, and a selling club with no reason to sell.

The rumour meter: real smoke, no fire

Two out of five. A proper beat reporter put Collins on the list, so it is not pub talk. But a list is a list. United have three names on it, and our reading is that Brentford and Fulham will both price their captains to be left alone.

The rest of the Brentford gossip sits lower. TEAMtalk’s Fraser Fletcher says Trabzonspor are preparing formal talks for Yehor Yarmolyuk, valued around £29m, and in the same breath that Brentford do not want to sell. Early Claims of Liverpool and Chelsea contact over El Hadji Malick Diouf were knocked down by TEAMtalk sources, relayed by GOAL, who call him untouchable this winter. Early And Kevin De Bruyne’s camp has sounded out Brentford, Fulham and Crystal Palace, says TEAMtalk’s Graeme Bailey. Being offered a legend is flattering. It is not a transfer. Early

What would move the needle on Collins? A bid well north of £40m, and a replacement lined up. TEAMtalk have Brentford tracking Lens centre-back Ismaelo Ganiou, which is exactly the sort of quiet groundwork this club does a year early.

Meanwhile, in west London

Man UnitedHello. We would like your captain.
BrentfordLovely. We are not selling this year. New policy.
Man UnitedFulham said that too.
BrentfordAlso, has anyone got a spare striker till December?

A BossFooty cartoon. Generic characters in club colours, not real people. Nobody actually said this.

The BossFooty view

That last bubble is the real story. The Collins saga will fill columns until February, but the next three games are about a missing centre-forward. Our numbers have Brentford as a split personality: three wins from five at home, none from five away. Thiago’s absence covers two home games against sides above them and a trip to Old Trafford.

The numbers say eighth is about right. The story says the next fortnight could wobble it, and a wobble is when selling clubs get nervous and buying clubs get bold. We still side with the club that spent £96m in the summer to stop being a shop.

The BossFooty call

Collins stays in January. Brentford take a point or two from the Thiago ban and do not buy a striker.

Confidence: fairly high on Collins, moderate on the rest

Share thisTelegramXFacebookThreads

BossFooty predictions are data analysis for discussion. They are not betting advice. BossFooty is independent and is not affiliated with the Premier League or any club.

Keep reading

More from BossFooty

Comments

Loading comments...

Ground photos by Wikimedia Commons contributors, used under Creative Commons licences. Photo credits