Robbed in the Derby, Now Meet the League’s Quietest Thieves: Birmingham City v Manchester United
Birmingham City lost the Second City derby on Sunday and left Villa Park with a list of complaints longer than the team sheet. A week later they get Manchester United, who have not lost in 12 matches and treat goals like a rationed commodity. One side feels robbed. The other has spent two months quietly taking things. This could get tetchy.
bossFOOTY.A drawing of the mood, not of any real event: Birmingham with their list of derby grievances, and United tiptoeing off with the points as usual.
The 60-second read
- The match: Birmingham City v Manchester United, Sunday 22 November, 12 noon UK time, St Andrew’s.
- The table: United are fourth on 18 points. Birmingham are 13th on six.
- Last week: Birmingham lost 1-0 at Aston Villa. United beat Crystal Palace 2-0.
- Our call: Birmingham City 0-1 Manchester United.
A team with a grievance meets a team that never gives you one
If you missed our derby report, the short version is that Birmingham had a penalty shout waved away, thought the winning goal was offside and were briefly a player short when it went in, all according to the BBC’s report carried by Yahoo Sports. They played well enough to feel hard done by. They also lost, and that makes it one win in ten.
United are the last opponents you want when you are looking for a break. Fourth in the table with just 12 goals in ten games, they win the way a cat crosses a room: slowly, and without knocking anything over. The fan site The Peoples Person, in a piece carried by Yahoo Sports, counts 12 matches unbeaten in all competitions.
There is a subplot too. Tom Garry noted in the Guardian earlier this month that Birmingham signed two Manchester United players in the summer. The report does not name them and we will not guess, but somebody in blue may have a point to prove to an old employer.
Shirt artwork is original BossFooty design in club colours, not official kit. Season figures from Fantasy Premier League.
The duel: Birmingham’s only goal source against United’s captain
Those cards are the match in two faces. Hurtre has seven of Birmingham’s 11 league goals. Take her out of the side and you have a team with four goals and a lot of nice build-up play.
Le Tissier is the opposite kind of story. She is a defender, she is the captain, and last weekend she opened the scoring against Palace from 25 yards on her 150th appearance for the club. When your centre-back is doing that, the forwards can relax a bit. Arguably United’s forwards have been relaxing since September.
What it means for our call: this is one striker against a defence that has conceded 11 in ten. Hurtre will need the game of her season, and both derby reports have her at the centre of the action at Villa Park: the penalty claim was hers, and so was the challenge that got a Villa defender sent off.
How they got here
- 5 AugustUnited appoint Eva Olid as head coach
- 14 NovemberUnited beat Crystal Palace 2-0. Twelve unbeaten in all competitions
- 15 NovemberBirmingham lose the derby 1-0 at Villa Park
- 18 NovemberUnited play Everton in the cup
- 22 NovemberBirmingham v United at St Andrew's
Reading the timeline: a new coach, a long unbeaten run and one small opening
Quick guide: read the top two lines together. United changed their head coach in pre-season and have barely lost since. That is not how these things are supposed to go. New managers are meant to need time.
The fourth line is Birmingham’s opening. Everton’s website lists a cup tie against United on Wednesday evening. A midweek game, then a noon kick-off on Sunday. If United rotate, or if legs are heavy, a side with a grudge and a home crowd has a chance.
But it is a small one. United are two points behind London City Lionesses in third. They have every reason to take this seriously.
In the dugout: the champion of Scotland and the champion of the second tier
Eva Olid arrived at United in August from Hearts, where she had just won the Scottish league title and been named manager of the season, according to her Wikipedia page. She replaced Marc Skinner. Three months in, she is fourth and unbeaten in 12. As job interviews go, it is going well.
Amy Merricks has been in charge of Birmingham since April 2024, her club’s Wikipedia page says, and won the second tier last season. The Guardian piece quoted her this month describing the gap between the divisions as an ocean. She is finding out how wide. We have seen no report that her job is in question, and a manager who won promotion six months ago has earned patience.
The mood in each camp
Birmingham: aggrieved, and that can be useful. Teams that feel wronged tend to start fast. United: serene. The Peoples Person, a fan site and therefore fan opinion, called the Palace win comfortable, which is the word United supporters have been waiting years to use about anything.
Transfer talk
The summer business between these clubs is the interesting part, even if we cannot name names from the report we have. For January, an honest line: we found no credible report linking anyone here with a move. Birmingham’s need is plain from the cards above. One scorer is not a plan.
The BossFooty view
Our call is Birmingham City 0-1 Manchester United. The numbers say away win, narrowly, because United do everything narrowly.
The story gives Birmingham more of a chance than the table does. They are angry, they are at home and United have a cup game in their legs. But angry does not score goals, and Birmingham have managed only 11. One-nil to the side that specialises in it. This is analysis for fun, not betting advice.
- Sky Sports: Women’s Super League table
- WSL Football: fixtures
- BBC Sport, via Yahoo Sports: Aston Villa beat Birmingham in WSL derby
- The Peoples Person, via Yahoo Sports: Man United 2-0 Crystal Palace
- The Guardian, via AOL: the gap between the WSL and the second tier
- Wikipedia: Eva Olid
- Wikipedia: Birmingham City Women
- Everton FC: upcoming cup tie v Manchester United
- Wikipedia: 2026-27 Women’s Super League
BossFooty predictions are data analysis for discussion. They are not betting advice. BossFooty is independent and is not affiliated with the Premier League or any club.
More from BossFooty
WSL Stories
Ten Defeats and an Ocean: Is Charlton’s Record Their Fault, or the System’s?
Charlton are the first WSL side to lose their first ten. The scorelines, the late promotion and the money say it is not only about them.
WSL Previews
The Team That Only Draws at Home Meets the Team That Never Draws: Arsenal v West Ham in the WSL
Arsenal have drawn all five home league games. West Ham have not drawn all season. One streak ends on Sunday. Our call: 2-1.
WSL Previews
Eight Goals, Five Unbeaten and No Way Through: Everton v Brighton in the WSL
Everton have just shut out the league's top scorers. Brighton have just lost 3-0 at home. Our call: 1-0.
Comments
Loading comments...
WSL StoriesbossFOOTY.
WSL PreviewsbossFOOTY.
WSL PreviewsbossFOOTY.