Four Years of Waiting, One Header, Three Arguments: Aston Villa 1-0 Birmingham City in the WSL
Four and a half years they waited for a Second City derby in the Women’s Super League, and when it finally came it was settled by a centre-half’s header, argued over by everybody, and finished with a Villa defender collecting a red card as a parting gift. Aston Villa 1-0 Birmingham City. Not pretty. Villa will not care one bit.
bossFOOTY.Our cartoonist’s version of the moment the derby turned: the centre-half arriving where a striker should be, and half of Birmingham appealing to anyone who would listen.
The 60-second read
- The score: Aston Villa 1-0 Birmingham City, Sunday 15 November, Villa Park.
- The goal: Mathilde Harviken, a second-half header from close range.
- The red card: Villa’s Oceane Deslandes, sent off in stoppage time.
- Our call: 1-1. Wrong. We had the tightness right and the winner missing.
- What it means: Villa climb to seventh on 13 points. Birmingham stay 13th on six.
A derby decided by a defender, which is very derby
The last time these two met in the WSL was May 2022, when an already-relegated Birmingham turned up at Villa Park and won 1-0 out of pure spite. The BBC’s Michael Emons, in a report carried by Yahoo Sports, reminds us of that, and it explains the mood: this was a fixture with a grudge in storage.
For an hour it looked like our 1-1 was the generous prediction, because nobody could score at all. Villa’s own match report has Jill Baijings and Amalie Vangsgaard both going close early, Sophie Baggaley busy in the Birmingham goal, and a crowd of 5,672 getting steadily more nervous.
Then the centre-half did the forwards’ job for them. The BBC times it at 76 minutes: Lynn Wilms headed the ball across goal and Harviken nodded in from close range. Villa’s site describes the same move starting from a wide free kick and puts it a little earlier, shortly after the hour. Take your pick on the clock. Nobody disputes the header.
Shirt artwork is original BossFooty design in club colours, not official kit. Season figures from Fantasy Premier League.
The cast: one at each end, and both wearing claret
Two cards, two ends of the pitch, one club. That tells you how this derby was won: not by the people paid to score, but by the people paid to stop it.
Harviken’s card has a nice wrinkle. Villa’s site points out she also opened the scoring against Birmingham in the cup last month. Some players have a favourite opponent. Hers lives just across the city.
Okuma’s card is the one Birmingham will be muttering about. The BBC credits her with a vital double save late on, after she had already kept out substitute Wilma Leidhammar early in the second half. Villa have conceded 16 this season, so a clean sheet in a derby is not a sentence we expected to type.
What it means for our call: we said one each because we could not see either defence holding out. Villa’s did. Sixteen goals shipped in nine games and then a shut-out when it mattered. Football is a strange business.
How the derby went
- First halfVilla have a goal ruled out
- First halfBirmingham want a penalty and get a corner
- Second halfOkuma saves from Leidhammar
- Second halfHarviken heads Villa in front. 1-0
- Late onOkuma makes a double save
- Stoppage timeDeslandes sent off
- Full timeAston Villa 1-0 Birmingham City
Reading the timeline: three arguments and a header
Quick guide for anyone who only saw the score: the list above is one goal surrounded by rows. Count them. A disallowed goal, a penalty shout, a disputed winner and a sending-off. That is a full derby in seven lines.
Start with the goal that did not count. Both reports agree Villa had the ball in the net in the first half and it was ruled out. They do not agree why. The BBC says offside, and adds that replays suggested the decision was wrong. Villa’s site says Deslandes was judged to have impeded the goalkeeper. When the home club’s own report and the BBC cannot agree on what the offence was, you can imagine the conversation in the stands.
Birmingham have their own file of complaints. The BBC’s report says they should have had a penalty when Lucy Parker caught Oceane Hurtre in the area, and that they felt Harviken’s winner was offside. It also notes they were briefly a player short when the goal went in, with defender Neve Herron off the pitch receiving treatment. So the visitors lost the derby and won the grievance count, which is no consolation at all.
And the red card. The BBC has Deslandes booked twice in 47 seconds. Villa’s site calls it a straight red for a mistimed challenge on Hurtre. Either way she walked, and either way it is the most derby thing imaginable: the match was won, the clock was nearly done, and somebody still found time to get sent off.
The dugout and the market: the interim is making a case
Brian Sorensen has been in interim charge since late September, when Villa sacked Natalia Arroyo with the club 13th, according to the season page on Wikipedia. They are now seventh. We have seen no report on whether the job becomes permanent, so we will not invent one, but a derby win and a climb of six places is the kind of CV you do not need to laminate.
The practical cost is Deslandes. A sending-off normally brings a suspension, though we have not seen the length confirmed, so treat that as the usual rule and not a fact. Villa go to Charlton next Sunday, the one side in the league yet to take a point, which is as gentle a week to be short of a defender as the fixture list offers.
For Birmingham, the table is the story. One win in ten, six points, 13th of 14, and Manchester United visiting next. Hurtre had seven league goals before this weekend and is carrying that attack on her own. On transfers, an honest line: we found no credible report linking anyone from this match with a move. But if Birmingham do not find her some help in January, the table will do the talking for them.
The BossFooty view
Our call was 1-1 and it finished 1-0 to Villa. A miss, and we own it. We read the derby as too tight to split and then a centre-half split it with her forehead. We also said neither defence could be trusted, and Villa’s promptly kept a clean sheet just to make a point.
The verdict: Villa are a different side under Sorensen, harder to play against and suddenly looking up the table instead of over their shoulder. Birmingham played well enough to feel robbed, and feeling robbed is worth exactly nought points. Second City bragging rights are claret and blue until the return game. This is analysis for fun, not betting advice.
BossFooty predictions are data analysis for discussion. They are not betting advice. BossFooty is independent and is not affiliated with the Premier League or any club.
More from BossFooty
WSL Stories
Ten Defeats and an Ocean: Is Charlton’s Record Their Fault, or the System’s?
Charlton are the first WSL side to lose their first ten. The scorelines, the late promotion and the money say it is not only about them.
WSL Previews
The Team That Only Draws at Home Meets the Team That Never Draws: Arsenal v West Ham in the WSL
Arsenal have drawn all five home league games. West Ham have not drawn all season. One streak ends on Sunday. Our call: 2-1.
WSL Previews
Eight Goals, Five Unbeaten and No Way Through: Everton v Brighton in the WSL
Everton have just shut out the league's top scorers. Brighton have just lost 3-0 at home. Our call: 1-0.
Comments
Loading comments...
WSL StoriesbossFOOTY.
WSL PreviewsbossFOOTY.
WSL PreviewsbossFOOTY.