Twenty-Three Minutes of Madness: Igor Thiago Leaves Brentford Without a Striker
Igor Thiago lasted 23 minutes at Brighton before raising an arm into an opponent’s face. It has cost Brentford their striker for three of the hardest games on their calendar, and they do not have another one.
bossFOOTY.The 60-second read
- What happened: a yellow card upgraded to red for violent conduct after a VAR review, in a 2-0 defeat at Brighton on 8 November.
- The ban: three matches: Everton at home, Manchester United away, Arsenal.
- The appeal: Brentford argued it was unintentional. It failed.
- The squeeze: 19-year-old back-up Kaye Furo is out with a serious foot injury, according to Sports Mole.
Shirt artwork is original BossFooty design in club colours, not official kit. Season figures from Fantasy Premier League.
One arm, three games
Twenty-three minutes into the game at Brighton, Chema Andres got close to Igor Thiago and the striker’s arm came up. The referee showed yellow. VAR had another look. Daily Cannon reported the on-field explanation: he had pushed his opponent in the face with force. Yellow became red, Brentford played more than an hour with ten men, and lost 2-0.
LiveScore called it a moment of madness, and it is hard to find a kinder phrase. Violent conduct carries an automatic three-match ban. Brentford appealed on the basis that the contact was accidental. The panel was not persuaded.
Brentford did try to make it go away. Reporter Nizaar Kinsella, as relayed by All Football, said the club would appeal on the grounds that the contact was unintentional, with a fallback argument that three games was excessive. It did not work: Daily Cannon, citing the BBC, reports that the appeal has been rejected, and relays the referee’s wording that Thiago “pushed his opponent in the face with force.” So the arithmetic at the top of this piece stands. One arm, three games, no discount.
Why this hurts more than a normal suspension
Because of who he is, when it is, and who is behind him.
Who he is: Brentford’s attack is built around Thiago. He had three goals and two assists in the six games before Brighton, and Keith Andrews has been saying for a year that he belongs in the conversation with Europe’s best strikers.
When it is: Everton, then Old Trafford, then Arsenal. That is a top-six side, a wounded giant with a new manager, and the champions.
It will not surprise you to learn who has been reading the calendar most closely. Daily Cannon is an Arsenal site, and its coverage of a Brentford striker’s suspension has been filed, entirely predictably, under what it means for Arsenal on 2 December. Fair enough: when the champions’ own corner of the internet is counting your suspended players for you, the fixture list has not been kind.
Who is behind him: nobody. Sports Mole reports teenage striker Kaye Furo has a serious foot injury. Their own audit of every club’s January needs had already listed attacking depth behind Thiago as Brentford’s gap. It took one red card to prove the point.
Strictly speaking, nobody is a slight exaggeration. Sports Mole’s Ben Knapton points out that Callum Wilson, now 34, has made six substitute appearances this season and could start, with Dango Ouattara or Kevin Schade as stand-in centre-forwards. That is a plan, but it is a plan built on a veteran who has not started and two wide men playing out of position, against Everton, Manchester United and Arsenal. It softens the problem without solving it.
The cost of one red card
- 8 NovSent off after 23 minutes at Brighton. Brentford lose 2-0
- AfterAppeal lodged. Appeal rejected
- 23 NovBanned: Everton at home
- 28 NovBanned: Manchester United away
- 2 DecBanned: Arsenal
The cruel detail for Everton fans to enjoy
Thiago loves playing Everton. He scored a hat-trick against them in January and two more in April. Five goals in two games. If you were designing a suspension to delight one specific fanbase, you would start it on the night Everton come to town.
Three out of five, and here is the working. Nobody has named a target, which keeps the needle off the top half. But the need has gone from “would be nice” to “have you seen the bench?”, and Brentford are not a club that ignores the obvious.
The story pushes it up, too. Keith Andrews’ side are eighth, and three games without his striker could turn a good autumn into an anxious winter. A manager in that spot asks for help in January, and usually gets it.
Meanwhile, at the Gtech
A BossFooty cartoon. Generic characters in club colours, not real people. Nobody actually said this.
The BossFooty view
Brentford will cope better than most. Andrews made his name on set pieces, they have the best home defensive record outside the top two, and they will make all three games ugly.
Keith Andrews, for his part, did not hide behind the officials. In the club’s own match report he accepted that the sending-off and the penalty gave Brighton a leg-up and said, “We need to learn from that, grow as a group.” That is the right tone, and it fits a side that usually wins by being harder to rattle than the opposition. The lesson just arrives at the most expensive possible moment.
But ugly only gets you draws, and Brentford already have five of those. Three games without a recognised striker is three games of hoping a corner drops kindly. Our preview has the Everton match as a 1-1. The bigger question is January: a club this well run does not usually get caught without cover twice.
- Daily Cannon: the red card and the referee’s explanation
- LiveScore: the sending-off
- Sports Mole: the games he misses and Furo’s injury
- All Football: the grounds for appeal
- Sky Sports: Thiago’s hat-trick at Everton
- Sports Mole: January priorities for every club
- Daily Cannon: Arsenal site on the rejected Thiago appeal
- Sports Mole: who could replace Thiago
- Brentford FC: official report from Brighton
BossFooty predictions are data analysis for discussion. They are not betting advice. BossFooty is independent and is not affiliated with the Premier League or any club.
More from BossFooty
Analysis
Postcards From the Break, Part Three: Wirtz Scores Twice, Robertson Passes Dalglish and Arsenal Hold Their Breath
The last postcards from the November break: Florian Wirtz hits two for Germany, Andy Robertson breaks Scotland's caps record in a 4-0 defeat, Zubimendi limps off and the long-haul flights land just before matchweek 11.
Transfers
Captain Wanted, Striker Banned, Shop Still Shut: Brentford’s Very Brentford November
Manchester United have Nathan Collins on their January list. Igor Thiago is banned for three games, one of them at Old Trafford. Brentford's answer to everything is a polite no.
Transfers
The Captain Fancies Old Trafford and the Coach Was Due the Sack: Fulham’s January Has Two Ends
Calvin Bassey is on Manchester United's list and reportedly open to it. Fulham want £40m-plus, lead the race for a Betis winger, and have a head coach who was tipped to be gone by now.
Comments
Loading comments...
AnalysisbossFOOTY.
TransfersbossFOOTY.
TransfersbossFOOTY.