The Great Hair-Pull Wars: Moyes, Lampard and the Rule Nobody Can Agree On
In January, David Moyes could not believe one of his defenders got a three-match ban for pulling an opponent’s hair. In November, Frank Lampard could not believe one of Moyes’s defenders got nothing for what he says was the same offence. Welcome to VAR.
bossFOOTY.The 60-second read
- January 2026: Everton’s Michael Keane is sent off for violent conduct for pulling Tolu Arokodare’s hair. Three-match ban, appeal rejected, Moyes livid.
- November 2026: Coventry lose 3-1 at Everton. Lampard says James Tarkowski pulled Caleb Yirenkyi’s hair and VAR should have punished it.
- The irony: same club, same alleged offence, opposite outcomes, and the two managers have swapped sides of the argument.
- Also that night: Moyes equalled Harry Catterick’s record of 592 games as Everton manager.
Shirt artwork is original BossFooty design in club colours, not official kit. Season figures from Fantasy Premier League.
Round one: Moyes against the system
Go back to January. Everton draw 1-1 with Wolves, and Michael Keane is shown a straight red card for violent conduct after grabbing Tolu Arokodare’s hair. That means three games. Everton appeal. A three-man panel says no.
Moyes was magnificent in his fury. Stats Perform reported him saying he was embarrassed for the officials and calling a three-game ban for a little pull of someone’s hair quite extraordinary. He wanted to know how that could be a sending-off when, in his view, a worse tackle in the same game went unpunished. It was a proper Moyes rant: eyebrows, disbelief, the works.
Round two: Lampard against the same system
Now to 6 November. Coventry go to Everton, take the lead, and lose 3-1 after Thierno Barry scores twice in four minutes. Afterwards Frank Lampard, who used to manage Everton, says VAR did not do its job on three big decisions. Top of his list, as IANS reported it: a hair pull by James Tarkowski on Caleb Yirenkyi that he felt should have been punished.
The detail matters here, because Lampard was not simply shouting at clouds. PA’s Carl Markham reports that the Coventry manager went to the fourth official at half-time and afterwards asked, “What is a hair pull and what is not?” PA also notes that the offence was downgraded from a red card this season, which is the quiet twist in this whole saga: the punishment Moyes thought was absurd in January has already been softened, and the argument has simply moved from how hard to punish it to whether anybody spots it at all.
So in ten months the rule has gone, in the eyes of the two men complaining, from far too harsh to not applied at all. And the club that was outraged to be punished for it is now the club accused of getting away with it. You could not script it better.
One offence, two verdicts
- Jan 2026Keane pulls Arokodare's hair. Red card, three-match ban
- Jan 2026Everton appeal. Rejected. Moyes fumes
- 6 Nov 2026Lampard says Tarkowski pulled Yirenkyi's hair. No action
- 6 Nov 2026Lampard fumes. Moyes equals a club record
Read that timeline as two lines of the same joke. In January an Everton defender pulls hair and gets three games. In November an Everton defender is accused of the same thing and gets nothing. Same club, same offence in the complainant’s eyes, opposite result. No wonder both managers look like men arguing with a vending machine.
The detail that makes it more than a moan is who is on each side. Moyes was the one fuming in January. Lampard is the one fuming now, after a defeat that left Coventry near the bottom three. Managers under pressure do not let these things go, and Lampard has not.
didn’t do its job
To be fair to everyone
We have not seen a ruling on the Tarkowski incident, only Lampard’s account of it, so treat it as his complaint, not a finding. Two incidents are never identical, and referees judge force and intent, not just hands on hair. But fans do not watch football with a law book. They see one defender banned for three games and another playing on, and they draw the obvious conclusion: nobody knows what the rule is this week.
Which is not to say Lampard is short of company. In a Flashscore column, former referees’ chief Keith Hackett gives his opinion that the Tarkowski incident should have been a penalty and a yellow card, and he is no kinder about the second Barry goal. That is one former official’s view and not a ruling, and Moyes, as Read Everton relays from his Match of the Day interview, said he had not seen the incident and did not think the ball struck Barry’s hand. Even Coventry’s own corner is not unanimous: over on VAVEL, a writer who introduces himself as a Coventry fan argues the hair-pull case and then turns on his own side with the line that “Lampard will undoubtedly be frustrated by City’s game management.” When your own supporters file the complaint and the confession in the same piece, the referee is not the only problem. Our position stays where it was: a grievance, possibly a good one, but not yet a finding.
Meanwhile, Moyes makes history
Lost in the noise: that win was Moyes’s 592nd game in charge of Everton, level with Harry Catterick’s club record. Everton are in the top six, Barry cannot stop scoring, and the next match takes Moyes past Catterick on his own. For a manager whose second spell was supposed to be a short-term rescue, that is quite a postscript.
For a sense of how the home end scored the evening, Read Everton, an independent Everton site, gave Barry nine out of ten and Tarkowski five, with the penalty incident named as the reason for the low mark. Blue-tinted judges docking their own centre-half is about as close to an admission as football gets, and it sits nicely beside a manager equalling a 592-game record on a night he did not much enjoy.
Meanwhile, in the VAR room
A BossFooty cartoon. Generic characters in club colours, not real people. Nobody actually said this.
The BossFooty view
Nobody is wrong here, which is the problem. Moyes had a point in January. Lampard may have a point now. What neither of them has is consistency from the people making the decisions, and that is the one thing managers, players and fans all ask for.
On the pitch it changes little. Everton go to Brentford on a roll, with their striker flying and their manager about to break a record. Coventry go into a relegation scrap with Palace feeling hard done by. Angry teams sometimes play well. Lampard will hope his is one of them.
- Stats Perform: Moyes on Keane’s ban, January 2026
- Evertonia: the appeal panel
- IANS: Lampard questions VAR
- Stats Perform: Lampard on three VAR calls
- AFP: Barry’s double and Moyes’s record
- Flashscore: Keith Hackett’s column on the Everton v Coventry decisions
- VAVEL: a Coventry fan’s lessons from the defeat
- Read Everton: player ratings from Everton v Coventry
BossFooty predictions are data analysis for discussion. They are not betting advice. BossFooty is independent and is not affiliated with the Premier League or any club.
More from BossFooty
WSL Stories
Ten Defeats and an Ocean: Is Charlton’s Record Their Fault, or the System’s?
Charlton are the first WSL side to lose their first ten. The scorelines, the late promotion and the money say it is not only about them.
WSL Previews
The Team That Only Draws at Home Meets the Team That Never Draws: Arsenal v West Ham in the WSL
Arsenal have drawn all five home league games. West Ham have not drawn all season. One streak ends on Sunday. Our call: 2-1.
WSL Previews
Eight Goals, Five Unbeaten and No Way Through: Everton v Brighton in the WSL
Everton have just shut out the league's top scorers. Brighton have just lost 3-0 at home. Our call: 1-0.
Comments
Loading comments...
WSL PreviewsbossFOOTY.
WSL PreviewsbossFOOTY.