Seven Up, Three Down: Man City Are Having a Season Last Seen in 1905
Enzo Maresca won his first seven league games as Manchester City manager. He has lost the next three. You have to go back to Sheffield Wednesday in 1904-05 to find anyone who managed that.
bossFOOTY.The 60-second read
- The run: seven wins, then defeats to Aston Villa (2-1), Brighton (1-0) and Nottingham Forest (3-1).
- The history: the Irish Examiner and Opta both note it has happened once before in the English top flight, 122 seasons ago.
- The twist: City had more of the ball and more chances in all three defeats.
- The damage: third in the table, six points behind Arsenal.
Shirt artwork is original BossFooty design in club colours, not official kit. Season figures from Fantasy Premier League.
How do you go from perfect to this?
For seven weeks, replacing Pep Guardiola looked like the easiest job in football. Turn up, pick Haaland, collect three points, go home. Enzo Maresca had City top with a perfect record and people were already writing the “seamless succession” pieces.
Then Villa beat them. Then Brighton won at the Etihad. Then Forest, who had not scored a single league goal at home all season, put two past them inside 18 minutes. Three different opponents, three different ways of losing, and one very quiet dressing room.
That Forest defeat is the one that stung, and you can measure it by who enjoyed it. Forest’s 1865 podcast titled its review “A world of Ryan Yates! Nottingham Forest 3-1 Manchester City”, and when your defeat becomes the name of somebody else’s happy episode it has been a long week. On the blue side, City Xtra, a City fan outlet, described the performance as toothless, which from that quarter is the equivalent of anyone else setting fire to a season ticket. All of that is colour, not evidence, but it tells you how far the mood has travelled from seven wins out of seven.
City's autumn, in five steps
- Aug to OctSeven league games, seven wins. Top of the table
- Game 8Aston Villa 2-1 City. First defeat
- Game 9City 0-1 Brighton. At home
- Game 10Forest 3-1 City. Delap scores twice
- NextFulham at home, 21 November
The stat that should worry them, and the one that should not
Here is the odd part. The Irish Examiner points out that City had more possession and more chances in every one of those defeats. At Villa they had 63% of the ball and 15 chances to eight. This is not a team being outplayed. It is a team shooting itself in the foot, reloading, and aiming at the other one.
Flashscore’s numbers back that up: four errors leading directly to goals this season, with only Sunderland and Hull making more. When your defensive company is two sides in the bottom eight, the problem is not the system. It is concentration.
Those errors are about to meet a personnel problem. PA’s report from the City Ground, carried by the Irish News, has Marc Guehi and Josko Gvardiol both coming off at half-time at Forest, and Flashscore reports that Guehi has since withdrawn from the England squad. The club has not confirmed what the injury is, so treat any diagnosis you read as a report and nothing more. What we can say is that a defence already handing out four goals through its own mistakes is the last one that wants to be reshuffled.
And then there is the Delap of it all. Opta notes he is only the second former City player to score twice against them in the Premier League, after Nicolas Anelka for Bolton in 2006. City sold him. He came back with a hammer.
I’m always concerned, even when we win games
The Guardiola shadow
One comparison doing the rounds is brutal. Guardiola took more than eight years at City before he lost three league games in a row. Maresca has done it in about three months. That is unfair, because Guardiola inherited nothing like this level of expectation, and also completely predictable, because this is what following a legend looks like. Every bad week is measured against the best decade the club has ever had.
For all that, nobody who matters is reaching for the panic button. There has been no David Ornstein line about emergency meetings and no Fabrizio Romano update on Maresca’s future; the reporting that exists comes from the press room, where PA’s Jonathan Veal quotes the manager after Forest as saying: “I’m always concerned, even when we win games.” That is either reassuring or the most manager sentence ever spoken. The supporters are less relaxed: on the Bluemoon forum the Enzo Maresca thread has reached page 56 after ten league games, seven of them wins, which is more than five pages a match. If the team will not press with intensity, the forum will. Three defeats in a row is a bad month, though, and a bad month is not yet a verdict.
Meanwhile, at the Etihad
A BossFooty cartoon. Generic characters in club colours, not real people. Nobody actually said this.
The BossFooty view
Blip or crisis? We lean blip, just. The chances are still there, Haaland is still Haaland, and three defeats built on individual errors are easier to fix than three defeats built on being second best.
But the Fulham game matters more than a home game against the side in 15th should. Lose that and “no panic” becomes very hard to say with a straight face. Our preview has City winning 2-1 and sweating for it. If they are behind at half-time, watch the directors’ box.
- Irish Examiner: City’s problems go beyond tactics
- Opta Analyst: Forest 3-1 Man City
- Stats Perform: Maresca wants balance
- Flashscore: errors leading to goals
- Dailysports: the Guardiola comparison
- PA via Irish News: Maresca after the Forest defeat
- Flashscore: Guehi withdraws from the England squad
- City Xtra: reaction to the Forest defeat (fan media)
- Bluemoon forum: the Maresca thread (fan opinion)
- 1865 podcast: episode titles (Forest fan opinion)
BossFooty predictions are data analysis for discussion. They are not betting advice. BossFooty is independent and is not affiliated with the Premier League or any club.
More from BossFooty
WSL Stories
Ten Defeats and an Ocean: Is Charlton’s Record Their Fault, or the System’s?
Charlton are the first WSL side to lose their first ten. The scorelines, the late promotion and the money say it is not only about them.
WSL Previews
The Team That Only Draws at Home Meets the Team That Never Draws: Arsenal v West Ham in the WSL
Arsenal have drawn all five home league games. West Ham have not drawn all season. One streak ends on Sunday. Our call: 2-1.
WSL Previews
Eight Goals, Five Unbeaten and No Way Through: Everton v Brighton in the WSL
Everton have just shut out the league's top scorers. Brighton have just lost 3-0 at home. Our call: 1-0.
Comments
Loading comments...
WSL PreviewsbossFOOTY.
WSL PreviewsbossFOOTY.